Historical Accuracy!

PaulF70 · May 12, 2024

Thought you guys might enjoy this. Passed thru Prescott, AZ last week with the fam (driving Grand Canyon->Phoenix). Its "Whiskey Row" is a historical site, with intact bars where Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday hung out.

Check out the description of this .36 '51 Colt Navy - it "has" "80 grains of black powder." 80 grains, eh? Quite a load for a .36!

Justin.44 · May 12, 2024

Maybe 80 between all 6 chambers lol

bigstick6017555 · May 12, 2024

Historical facts, you really have to wonder sometimes

Sam squanch · May 12, 2024

I think most of these people are very enthusiastic, but very short on facts. Like the lady telling me a 1884 trapdoor was used in a civil war skirmish…

PaulF70 · May 12, 2024

80 grains total was the thought I had too...

I thought of pointing out the error to the nice ladies running the museum, but I don't think it would have gone over well.

kh54 · May 12, 2024

Well it’s a “muzzleloader” so you pour 80 grains down the barrel, of course. Everyone knows that.

Phil Coffins · May 12, 2024

PaulF70 said:
80 grains total was the thought I had too...

I thought of pointing out the error to the nice ladies running the museum, but I don't think it would have gone over well.

When I find these things and have a definitive answer with a source they can check I bring it their attention. Done politely it some times has helped them to have a better understanding of the subject. The least amount of effort has worked a few times.

rodwha · May 12, 2024

PaulF70 said:
Thought you guys might enjoy this. Passed thru Prescott, AZ last week with the fam (driving Grand Canyon->Phoenix). Its "Whiskey Row" is a historical site, with intact bars where Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday hung out.

Check out the description of this .36 '51 Colt Navy - it "has" "80 grains of black powder." 80 grains, eh? Quite a load for a .36!

Made me wonder if someone confused the weight of the ball for the powder charge since a .380” ball weighs about 80 grns I believe.

Smokerr · May 12, 2024

I was at an Air Museum once, the Air Exhibits were all correct. But a piece of WWII air field equipment caught my attention, something was not jiving.

Lo and behold, a 2nd Air Museum had the type that had been mentioned and it had all the gear on it per the details. Hmmmm.

So I went down sleuth lane and found that the first one had totally blew it, it was not an air field service crawler, it was a Glider size dozer. Only common aspect was they were both crawlers.

I contact the first Museum and told them they had a wonderful Clark Dozer but it was not The Cletrac Service crawler they had it labeled as.

Brazos John · May 12, 2024

PaulF70 said:
Thought you guys might enjoy this. Passed thru Prescott, AZ last week with the fam (driving Grand Canyon->Phoenix). Its "Whiskey Row" is a historical site, with intact bars where Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday hung out.

Check out the description of this .36 '51 Colt Navy - it "has" "80 grains of black powder." 80 grains, eh? Quite a load for a .36!

We spent a week in Prescott in April. I want to move there!
It's a great little town, with a cool Old Town and Whiskey Row around the Courthouse. The Palace Bar has some great, if slightly inaccurate, displays of old guns, old mining stuff, and more old stuff. The day we were there, there was a group of folks dressed like they had been to a SASS shoot. And everyone was heeled, including the bargirls. Touristy, but authentically old.
The surrounding hills and granite dells are so cool!
And I couldn't believe the Indian petrographs on hilltops that were undamaged by vandals!
That could never happen near Houston, or most any other big city that I know of!

Smokerr · May 13, 2024

I have roamed that area of Arizona (actuality quite a bit of it overall) in past years. Other than Phoenix, its quite the place with a huge variety of terrain and features. Too hot in the Summer of course, but man it was some great excursions.

One I went the right direction on as it was a miles long gravel road that had a massive cliff on the other side of the road. Man I hate heights like that. Happy to hug the inside of that one. Of East of Mesa and I believe one of the major reservoirs if memroy serves right, Dam built by Imported Italian Stone Masons.

mikesto44 · May 13, 2024

Remember most tour guides an museum people are told what to say. The artifacts are labeled sometimes by lack of actual information.

Packrat · May 13, 2024

Ames 1849 Rifleman's Knife

Packrat · May 13, 2024

Posted on wrong page, sorry

Wncman · May 13, 2024

i don’t believe you could get 80 grains in the cylinder, maybe all of them combined. And certainly not a ball on top. And I’m certain I’d nit pull the trigger

Whitworth · May 13, 2024

I think someone was hard hearing and heard 80, not 18 grains.

shorthair · Jun 6, 2024

Sam squanch said:
I think most of these people are very enthusiastic, but very short on facts. Like the lady telling me a 1884 trapdoor was used in a civil war skirmish…

Sad to think people like these are educating our kids, no wonder each new generation is dumber than the proceeding ones.

Historical Accuracy!

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

PaulF70

40 Cal

Attachments

Justin.44

54 Cal.

bigstick6017555

40 Cal

Sam squanch

69 Cal.

PaulF70

40 Cal

kh54

45 Cal.

Phil Coffins

69 Cal.

rodwha

58 Cal.

Smokerr

45 Cal.

Brazos John

Not A Troll

Smokerr

45 Cal.

mikesto44

50 Cal.

Packrat

45 Cal.

Packrat

45 Cal.

Wncman

45 Cal.

Whitworth

69 Cal.

shorthair

40 Cal

Latest posts

Historical Accuracy!

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

40 Cal

Attachments

54 Cal.

40 Cal

69 Cal.

40 Cal

45 Cal.

69 Cal.

58 Cal.

45 Cal.

Not A Troll

45 Cal.

50 Cal.

45 Cal.

45 Cal.

45 Cal.

69 Cal.

40 Cal

Join the conversation!

Join today and get all the highlights of this community direct to your inbox. It's FREE!