• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Idaho Lewis Modified NASA lube

L & R
Shop deals on ebay
Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
chorizo

chorizo

58 Cal.
MLF Supporter
Joined
Aug 14, 2022
Messages
2,042
Reaction score
5,283
Location
idaho
I recently received a brick of Idaho Lewis' Modified NASA lube. Reading some of his old posts and over at his old forum, he liked it thin and sticky, claiming (and I don't doubt him) that thin is more accurate.. The smell reminded me of something, but couldn't place it.

Upon investigating his modification I found that it is synthetic 2 cycle motor oil! Approximately 5 ozs per pound of NASA. I immediately connected smell with formula. Now that doesn't jive with all the hoopla about "natural, non-petroleum based" lubes. As Gen Ripper said, "How does that fit with your post-war communist conspiracy". I don't know what was in the NASA lube. (~ Lubes ~)

So I decided, WTH, I am going to try that too. So I took 1 lb of my hard lube of mutton tallow 1 part to 5 parts beeswax and 1 part solid ALOX lube and a tablespoon of olive oil and added 2.5 ozs of synthetic 2 cycle oil to it and bricked it up. While it isn't NASA lube (more like Basco sheepherder lube) It is going to get a try out on some REAL 50 cal 320 gr and some REAL 58 cal 444 gr in a heads up comparison to Idaho Lewis lube.

According to Lewis, thin is better for accuracy. As I tin these up anyway, it should not matter. We shall see.

IdahoLewis quote: " I have found a Thinner lube to be Superior to Thicker. I like it SOFT, where it will just hold in the Grooves. Place an 1/8” Wool Felt Wad (Oversize) Between the Powder and Bullet lubed as i just spoke of, It just Doesn’t get any better than that"
 
Last edited:
One of the more popular lubes among BPCR guys starts out with a tube of graphite impregnated chassis grease. I made some up once but don't recall the rest of the formula but it's probably out there somewhere. It played well with BP.
 
longcruise said:
One of the more popular lubes among BPCR guys starts out with a tube of graphite impregnated chassis grease. I made some up once but don't recall the rest of the formula but it's probably out there somewhere. It played well with BP.
Click to expand...
We used to put synthetic grease over the balls in our cap and ball pistols. Kept the running for 50-60 shots easy.
 
chorizo said:
So I took 1 lb of my hard lube of mutton tallow 1 part to 5 parts beeswax and 1 part solid ALOX lube and a tablespoon of olive oil and added 2.5 ozs of synthetic 2 cycle oil to it and bricked it up. While it isn't NASA lube (more like Basco sheepherder lube) It is going to get a try out on some REAL 50 cal 320 gr and some REAL 58 cal 444 gr in a heads up comparison to Idaho Lewis lube
Click to expand...
Not all synthetic 2 cycle oil may be equal. I have done some limited experimenting with Stihl 2 cycle synthetic oil mixed into some bullet lubes and at least initially, seems to work well, particularly with leading. I believe your friend in Idaho suggests the Stihl oil. I know I can tell when I using it in my 2 cycle engines as the exhaust has a definite unique waxy smell to it.

It will interesting to hear your test results.
 
Last edited:
SDSmlf said:
Not all synthetic 2 cycle oil may be equal. I have done some limited experimenting with Stihl 2 cycle synthetic oil mixed into some bullet lubes and at least initially, seems to work well, particularly with leading. I believe your friend in Idaho suggests the Stihl oil. I know I can tell when I using it in my 2 cycle engines as the exhaust has a definite unique waxy smell to it.

It will interesting to here your test results.
Click to expand...
I used homelite synthetic and it has the same distinct waxy smell but a brighter green color. It will be next week as the weather here is still locked in old man winter's grip. I can't believe there is that much difference between them, at least in this application.
 
Last edited:
@SDSmlf I went up the MSDS sheets for both Ryobi/Homelite 2 cycle synthetic and Stihl 2 Cycle synthetic. Homelite is "70-90%" Solvent-refined heavy paraffinic distillate" and "bio-degradable within 60-90 days"...mixture of the additives is a proprietary blend in type and amounts but none of the items are considered hazardous.

Stihl is 80-100% Oak Palm based and made from natural oils and also biodegradable and additives in amounts and types is also proprietary and non-hazardous. Seems the Stihl has a more "natural" plant based oil whereas the homelite has carbon hydro-carbon based oil that is also biodegradable.

I guess I will find out.
 
Last edited:
chorizo said:
I used homelite synthetic and it has the same distinct waxy smell but a brighter green color. It will be next week as the weather here is still locked in old my winter's grip. I can't believe there is that much difference between them, at least in this application.
Click to expand...
I honestly don’t know if will make a difference, just that I found that Stihl has a unique smell to it, quite different than the Homelite, though I haven’t compared them head to head. Got a six pack of the stuff when I bought a chainsaw and Stihl had a promotion on that added a few extra years of warranty if you purchased the oil with the saw.

Don’t know how many ‘synthetics’ they have to squeeze to get the oil out, but the 2 cycle synthetic seems to play nice with blackpowder. Have not tried it with any of the subs.

As I mentioned previously, curious to hear about your results. I’m about out of my lube and will be mixing some up soon.
 
SDSmlf said:
Not all synthetic 2 cycle oil may be equal. I have done some limited experimenting with Stihl 2 cycle synthetic oil mixed into some bullet lubes and at least initially, seems to work well, particularly with leading. I believe your friend in Idaho suggests the Stihl oil. I know I can tell when I using it in my 2 cycle engines as the exhaust has a definite unique waxy smell to it.

It will interesting to hear your test results.
Click to expand...
I learned the hard way that not all 2 cycle oil is the same. I used 2 cycle oil intended for liquid cooled engines in an air cooled engine. Fried the air cooled engine. Saw dealer told me I wasn't the only one to have assumed outboard motor oil would work in a chainsaw. Made my feel a little better.....
 
Rawhide67 said:
Did something happen, seems like he was around not long ago. Or am I mixing him up with someone else?
Click to expand...
Supposedly he got really tired of the drama and repetitiveness of the forums, even his own forum, so he quit participating sometime last fall, I believe.

Wealth of knowledge on long range shooting and accuracy. I have tried to build some of my carbines based upon information I gleamed from his "hot rod" builds. I believe @Idaho Ron could tell you more as my information is second hand at best. He communicated with him directly.
 
Last edited:
DCAN said:
Chain saw bar oil might be worth a try on patches. Surely someone has already done it.
Click to expand...
This specifically is being used in small amounts for bullet lube to soften it and has an OP wad between powder and bullet. I think the petro-carbon oil might cause you some issues on patches, powder and fouling.
 

Similar threads

Golden Child
Noob issues
2 3 4
Replies
71
Views
5K
Golden Child
Golden Child
W
Journal of a Traditional Alberta Muzzleloader Elk Hunt
Replies
0
Views
2K
Walkingeagle
W
Flint62Smoothie
Info and MSDS for "Ballistol"
Replies
11
Views
2K
noahmercy
N
J
Traditional Varnish info
Replies
3
Views
1K
dave_person
dave_person

Latest posts

Back
Top