• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

1855 Sidehammer Root original & reproduction

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

kh54

45 Cal.
Joined
Jan 26, 2021
Messages
703
Reaction score
1,126
I'm not normally a braggart (God knows I don't have much to brag about) so let's just call it sharing. OK, so I admit it - I just want to share these two guns. I don't know why I'm so enamored of the pocket-size revolvers, but I've always loved small gadgets and these sort of fit that. The first gun pictured is my only original Colt, an 1855 Root in .28 caliber (1st model), manufactured in 1860, that I picked up about a year ago. The accoutrements are also all original, with the exception of the cleaning rod, and I'm not sure about the wrench - I just don't remember. The round and conical balls I cast with the original mold. The case is from Bill Shumate, who makes the most beautiful cases that I've seen. I bought this gun to round out my Colt collection because I couldn't find a reproduction. Although I believe it's shootable, I am fearful of breaking parts. So, I continued to look for a reproduction to shoot but rarely have I seen any available - once only on this forum and once or twice on GB.

The second gun pictured is a Palmetto reproduction that I recently bought from forum member @johnh (thanks again John!) Yes! My patience paid off! But the gun is so pretty (unfired I think, like new in box, with papers - a dream!) I can't bring myself to shoot it either. So I decided to put together a cased set with reproduction accoutrements. The case is an "antique" repurposed to fit this gun by an ebay seller in Great Britain. I should have held out for a Bill Shumate case. Looking at all the glue spills on the otherwise nice blue velvet fabric is all you need to know about the quality. The case isn't bad, just not as nice as one of Bill's.

The Palmetto reproduction is a bit of a fantasy gun, I believe. It appears to represent a 5th or 6th model (.31 caliber, round barrel) but the barrel is the same length (3-7/16-inch) as the 1st model and not the 3-inch barrels of the Model 5 and Model 6, or the 4-inch barrels of the Model 5A and Model 6A. It also has no engraving on the cylinder, and I understand that all Root cylinders were engraved, with the exception of the few fluted cylinders Colt made for the Root. (I got this information from College Hill Arsenal, so feel free to offer corrections if their information is incorrect.) I also wish that Palmetto had hidden their modern stamps (serial number, proof marks, warning, advertising, etc.) like Uberti has learned to do. They really show up on this small gun.

Anyway, I love both guns!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_6613.JPG
    IMG_6613.JPG
    475.8 KB
  • IMG_6614.JPG
    IMG_6614.JPG
    443.8 KB
Ah gosh, thanks fellers! I like collecting, not just the guns but also the accessories to put together cased sets that approach historic cased sets. I have to spend my kids' inheritance some way - may as well be this as another expensive hobby. But then I haven't yet tried collecting classic cars...
 
.... But then I haven't yet tried collecting classic cars...
Cars you have to buy insurance, get licensed, have a place to keep them out of the weather, routine maintence, repairs (not to mention finding a garage knows how to fix them) etc etc etc ... no end of expenses. This hobby is way better, IMO.

- from another with the collector sickness -
 
Last edited:
Ah gosh, thanks fellers! I like collecting, not just the guns but also the accessories to put together cased sets that approach historic cased sets. I have to spend my kids' inheritance some way - may as well be this as another expensive hobby. But then I haven't yet tried collecting classic cars...
You're not bragging, you're sharing what a lot of us wouldn't normally see. Chasing down rare accessories can be venturing into a big buck collecting field of it's own. Well done cased sets are classily and always a treat to see. Thanks for the tip about the cases from across the pond, I've seen them listed and been tempted.
 
Ah gosh, thanks fellers! I like collecting, not just the guns but also the accessories to put together cased sets that approach historic cased sets. I have to spend my kids' inheritance some way - may as well be this as another expensive hobby. But then I haven't yet tried collecting classic cars...
those are very nice.i never hsve seen them before. thank you for sharing
 
Back
Top