I have to rethink the spare cylinder idea

AlexB said:

My 1858 replicas did not come with spare cylinders but every one has one now and a pouch to carry it.

Click to expand...

I just want to clarify what you mean. When you say "everyone" are you referring to shooters or to pistols now being supplied with spare cylinders by manufacturers? In a period of just over a year now I have bought four Colt Ubertis, an 1849 Pocket Model, 1862 Police Model, and a Whitneyville and First Model Dragoon. None came with spare cylinders but maybe they have started that since. If I ever carry those Dragoons through the woods on an outing I don't want a spare cylinder. That way I have an excuse to carry both. As far as Hollywood and swapping spare cylinders, what comes to mind for me are scenes from the Young Riders. Correct or not if it had been made in the 50s or 60s they would have been carrying Colt Model 1873s.

nick_1 said:

heck. I have 3 spares for my 1858. There is just no evidence that this was done in the 1860s or 70's in America. And NO, Pale rider is not evidence.

Click to expand...

I beg to differ, as I posted on page one of this thread evidence of just that:

https://www.muzzleloadingforum.com/...k-the-spare-cylinder-idea.185929/post-2713559

It is fact they were not general issue in the military for a couple reasons, the first being handguns were only generally issued to cavalry and officers, both equipped with sabers that never need be reloaded. Cavalry had the doctrine of using their revolvers to close to saber range, and they could carry extra pistols because they were mounted and didn't have to carry them afoot, they usually carried a carbine or shotgun as well. The doctrine was to close to the point where you could use the sword. With officers it was sort of the same, they weren't fighting at range, they were directing when at range, and their sidearm was a symbol of authority and to be used when things got close, and they also had the sword. Most troops, infantry, artillery etc., were not issued handguns so they had no need for extra cylinders either.

Civilian law enforcement Wells Fargo employees etc. did have a use for them and it is documented that they did avail themselves of extra cylinders. Remington specifically advertised the sale of extra cylinders. Also, as cartridges were invented and came into use, many continued carrying their 1858s, but with a cartridge conversion cylinder and a spare C&B in case cartridges were not available.

Flint1 said:

I just want to clarify what you mean. When you say "everyone" are you referring to shooters or to pistols now being supplied with spare cylinders by manufacturers? In a period of just over a year now I have bought four Colt Ubertis, an 1849 Pocket Model, 1862 Police Model, and a Whitneyville and First Model Dragoon. None came with spare cylinders but maybe they have started that since. If I ever carry those Dragoons through the woods on an outing I don't want a spare cylinder. That way I have an excuse to carry both. As far as Hollywood and swapping spare cylinders, what comes to mind for me are scenes from the Young Riders. Correct or not if it had been made in the 50s or 60s they would have been carrying Colt Model 1873s.

Click to expand...

I mean every one of mine has one because I aquired another one for them.
Was easy to think of and do,I aint that smart.
So I figure if I thought of it so did someone else.
Their brains were actually smarter than ours.

AlexB said:

I mean every one of mine has one because I aquired another one for them.
Was easy to think of and do,I aint that smart.
So I figure if I thought of it so did someone else.
Their brains were actually smarter than ours.

Click to expand...

Maybe, maybe not. People have tended to become smarter than the previous generations. Until recently apparently…

For the sake of your children, kill the internet.

Bad Karma said:

For the sake of your children, kill the internet.

Click to expand...

We are much dumber than they were of that I have no doubt.
We produce college graduates who cannot define a woman and believe a man can menstrate.

Ed C. said:

Now that is very interesting. For good cap fit I've always just swapped out to Slixshots on the revolvers never figuring it would affect accuracy. Now I'll have to try a set of TOTW stainless.

Click to expand...

Me too !

I still go with its holyweard. Horse troopers carried carbines and why have a spare cylinder that will not fit your gun vs hello have a repeating carbine.