Kibler Brown Bess?

Shop deals on ebay
the hawken shop
Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Would you buy a Kibler Brown Bess kit?

  • Yes

    Votes: 108 71.1%

  • No

    Votes: 44 28.9%
  • Total voters
    152
Yes!
Make a Long Land
And 1728 French

These will cover the F&I war and the REV.

And since Kibler will do his homework and make them correctly, they will be the most correct and not need defarb modifications.
 
Youngblood said:
Yes!
Make a Long Land
And 1728 French

These will cover the F&I war and the REV.

And since Kibler will do his homework and make them correctly, they will be the most correct and not need defarb modifications.
Click to expand...
I'm pretty certain he gets a computer alert whenever his business is mentioned: then, he reaches for the Excedrin, as calls for this-musket-that-musket, here a 20 ga. Bess, there a Long Land, look out, now a 1728 French! Let the poor guy do what he does best, which is not getting involved in picky-picky re-enactor stuff! (JMHO: no offence meant!) I re-enacted over ten years, so love 'em all! :thumb: This comment is made in good humor, don't fire back!
 
Often seen are folks kicking the current reproduction Besses & Charlys to the curb - even the lofty Pedersolis and heavens forbid anyone goes to the Indian suppliers ( That would bring at least a month of comments on the forum) IF Mr. Kibler decided to do such a kit - I have no doubt it would be of the highest quality - that's why at least I would like to get one.
 
ZUG said:
Here is my thought on this: The majority of people that use a Bess are the new reenactors and they don't care what it truly represents as long as it looks like a Bess and goes boom when the trigger is pulled. If they stay in the "game" for some time, then they will want something that DOES look like a real Bess. These are the people that will want a Kibler or other high-quality Bess. How many of those are out there - who knows? For me I would one as a wall hanger and not cost me an arm or a leg.
Click to expand...
The re-enactor is a small sub-group of a larger sub-group of traditional ML enthusiasts whose numbers slowly decrease every year as the older guys age out.
Younger, new members numbers are not keeping up with the older guys giving it up.
That’s my impression, anyway. Hope I am wrong.
 
springfield art said:
That question as to which Model to offer would be a contentious point; re-enactors doing various periods would want their favorite Model!! Maybe choosing a variant that covers the most "mileage" would have to suffice.
Click to expand...

I reckon that whatever model was the most common around the time of the Revolutionary War would be the winner. Before that there seems to be little interest, apart from the FIW, and afterwards even less.
 
Youngblood said:
Yes!
Make a Long Land
And 1728 French

These will cover the F&I war and the REV.

And since Kibler will do his homework and make them correctly, they will be the most correct and not need defarb modifications.
Click to expand...
He’s already said a Bess in his video… that would be what sells — not some Schangal gun.
 
One thing for sure, if he goes ahead with the project it will be the closest thing to an original that most of us would ever hope to own. Kind of late in the game for me and I haven't really had much interest in military arms of the era, but even so, I would buy one and if he announces a go ahead, I will be at the top of the list.
Robin
 
Grenadier1758 said:
Bear in mind there are many options and variations of the land pattern muskets that were used. So many that I doubt it would be practical for Jim to develop a CNC manufacturing program for all the variations.
Click to expand...

Seems like there’s a few shops developing a CNC 1756 long land pattern for the 250th. The 1756 land pattern seems to be the direction most are headed, makes sense it was the long land variant that was most used throughout the entire war AWI.

I’m going to be in the market for one if they’re available. Curious as to see what kind of modifications are made for cost effectiveness, my guess is that will be mostly in the stock and barrel, I’ve viewed around a dozen 1756’s, they all vary from extremely large to at 13lbs to a models 10 lbs. some have brass hardware that is beefier with larger forearms, some have leaner forearms. Some breech’s are around 1.400 while other’s are as large as 1.50, this is largely because have two (sometimes three, one on the bottom) flats filed on the breech where others just have one.
 
145 Votes with 71% voting for a Kibler bess. The percentage is good , the overall volume..not so good.
I don’t frequent the ALR sight often and wonder how that vote is going.
 

Similar threads

Josh-the-blacksmith
Pedersoli brown bess carbine.
Replies
4
Views
440
barracudadave67
B
Benjamin_Martin
Need help identifying Revolutionary War era musket 🙏
2 3
Replies
48
Views
4K
Mle1822
Mle1822
tak
Kibler’s Longrifles Tour
Replies
2
Views
857
tak
tak
Smokey Plainsman
Just Ordered a Kibler Fowling Piece!
Replies
8
Views
983
duca
duca
FlintlockMilitaryRifle
  • Locked
SOLD very nice Veteran Arms 1st Land Pattern Brown Bess for sale!
2
Replies
38
Views
5K
FlintlockMilitaryRifle
FlintlockMilitaryRifle

Latest posts

Back
Top