• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Search results

the hawken shop
L & R
Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
  1. J

    Is this the real deal?

    Hah, Success, I think a certain critical mass of people contacting that seller has finally broken through. He just added to the description this is a reproduction based on the serial #. I think what really happened is it was taking too much of his email time to keep getting told the same thing...
  2. J

    Is this the real deal?

    OldMaineWoodsMan You are 100% correct. Lesson learned. Here is one of my favorites from reading his reviews: F linesntines A+(9) 12/25/2020 886017253 junk selling son of a gripe, I throw away better than these,sent mostly 7.62 , not 308 like listed, lots are not reloadable Response (left on...
  3. J

    Is this the real deal?

    Waterman Lily Ormsby (September 9, 1809 – November 1, 1883) As in DIED in 1883. This gun was made after 1970. this=fraud
  4. J

    Is this the real deal?

    Good news, I've been outbid. As of right now the bid is $1025, so hopefully the high bidder knows what he/she is bidding on. I am still curious to hear the response from GB about intentional fraud though.
  5. J

    Is this the real deal?

    Yes I will definitely ask questions here before bidding again.
  6. J

    Is this the real deal?

    Yes, we have conclusively established this is a 2nd or 3rd gen, and not original
  7. J

    Is this the real deal?

    If it were to be what it was advertised to be, what the seller confirmed in an email to me, I would have been interested. Yes, you read that correctly, GunBroker is currently saying even in the case of fraud, bids are binding, which is ridiculous, and I'm sure will be corrected once it reaches...
  8. J

    Is this the real deal?

    It clearly is not from 1860. GunBrocker just told me via email all bids are binding even in the case of fraud, so I have escalated this complaint up the flagpole. I think when the more senior muckity mucks at Gunbrocker see this response they will cancel my bid.
  9. J

    Is this the real deal?

    What do you guys think fair market value for this auction is?
  10. J

    Is this the real deal?

    Serial 213550 is right out
  11. J

    Is this the real deal?

    I did tell him the serial# proves this was not made in the 1860s
  12. J

    Is this the real deal?

    I emailed him asking if it was an original 1860 from the 1860s and he replied "correct"
  13. J

    Is this the real deal?

    Thank you. The seller is claiming it is an original 1860. I've asked to cancel my bid. The gun clearly is in too fine a condition to be genuine 1860s
  14. J

    Is this the real deal?

    https://www.gunbroker.com/item/896238843 gunbroker item #896238843 1860 colt "army" I'm bidding on this one. Can people please confirm this is an original and not a reproduction? Thank you in advance :0)
  15. J

    Is this 1858 an original "real deal?"

    The fact that the photos are such they do not show info is enough evidence to show a "consciousness of guilt" Seller clearly knows what he is doing.
  16. J

    Is this 1858 an original "real deal?"

    Thank you everyone, I've learned quite a bit. Still wet behind the ears though...
  17. J

    Is this 1858 an original "real deal?"

    Except that Karma is infallible...
  18. J

    Is this 1858 an original "real deal?"

    I think gunbroker is basically caveat emptor
  19. J

    Is this 1858 an original "real deal?"

    Question, if I wanted to buy and original some time in the future, what price should I expect to pay?
  20. J

    Is this 1858 an original "real deal?"

    If I give you $1,100, will YOU throw in a holster 🤣 I'm completely kidding of course. Where did you find such a nice ones? And may I ask what would the originals sell for if I wanted to by an original, and where might there be one available?
Back
Top