-
Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.
We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.
Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103
1862 Tower
- Thread starter Kelpie
- Start date
Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:
Sad to see but very typical of the fate of a lot of them. A shotgun was far more saleable than a 40" rifle musket.
Sam squanch
69 Cal.
- Joined
- Oct 9, 2019
- Messages
- 3,167
- Reaction score
- 4,522
If the bore is ok, it may be a great shooter! Failing that, it is definitely worth something for the parts.
It looks like a Bannerman's special. His company bought hundreds of CW firearms and made slight modifications to the barrel and stocks.
Sold many of them as smoothbore shotguns like the one in the pictures.
Not any real collector value but they are a part of American history.
Sold many of them as smoothbore shotguns like the one in the pictures.
Not any real collector value but they are a part of American history.
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2020
- Messages
- 3,090
- Reaction score
- 6,946
I'd start looking for a barrel, stock and small parts needed to bring the lock and the other good parts back to life in a proper rifle. Good project.
Dunlap may have replacement forearms to repair the stock.
http://dunlapwoodcrafts.com/
Hoyt can stretch and line the barrel.
http://dunlapwoodcrafts.com/
Hoyt can stretch and line the barrel.
- Joined
- Jul 24, 2018
- Messages
- 4,497
- Reaction score
- 5,647
I have an otherwise unmessed with P53 that was bored to a shotgun. According to the story it was brought home by a Confederate soldier then turned into a bird gun. For about $800, 10 years ago, I figured I'd buy the Story and the Gun since it's a real P53, and I gave it to my Dad as a wall hanger.
Any thoughts I had of having it relined went away after I found a few Parker Hales.
If you look around, MAYBE you can turn up a Parker Hale musketoon barrel and a EuroArms stock w/metal and use the original lock. Otherwise it's basically a wallhanger.
Any thoughts I had of having it relined went away after I found a few Parker Hales.
If you look around, MAYBE you can turn up a Parker Hale musketoon barrel and a EuroArms stock w/metal and use the original lock. Otherwise it's basically a wallhanger.
Why not just send it to Bobby Hoyt to see how safe it is to shoot as it currently is, and if it needs work, then decide what to do.
For myself, everytime I read one of these discussions where people recommend to take a weapon that has been HONESTLY reworked into something other than what it was when it came out of the manufacturers shop, and to return it to its original specifications; I can't help but think that they are recommending for someone to create an "honest fake". Because, even if the person today attempts to put distinguishing marks on it to prevent the weapon from being identified as a whole original, at some point in the future, an unscrupulous person will probably be tempted to sell it as a fake.
Left alone, it lives on honestly as what it truly is. A Civil War era percussion rifle that has been shortened & bored out to become a smoothbore. Whether this work was done in the 19th Century by a gunsmith for the local trade, or by some firm like Bannerman's in the 20th Century for the burgeoning, rebirth of muzzleloading here in the United States, to me makes little difference. It was honest work performed by honest tradesmen, for sale to people looking for a honest, low cost shotgun that could get the job done.
I think the gun has a simple beauty, similar to an English shotgun, and probably handles reasonably well.
Edit:
Not every surviving example of a firearm that was manufactured in whatever era, needs to be in pristine condition, nor looking exactly like an original. Honest wear & tear, coupled with the vagaries of whatever man & time has inflicted upon it, is what makes our sport so interesting.
Just like Joe Bonamassa wants all of his road guitars to have a story behind them, instead of being pristine examples that got purchased & stuck under someone's bed for 40-50 years; I think that guns like the one in the OP are far more interesting & important, than a high dollar collector's version of the same gun. ESPECIALLY, if there's a documented story behind it.
For myself, everytime I read one of these discussions where people recommend to take a weapon that has been HONESTLY reworked into something other than what it was when it came out of the manufacturers shop, and to return it to its original specifications; I can't help but think that they are recommending for someone to create an "honest fake". Because, even if the person today attempts to put distinguishing marks on it to prevent the weapon from being identified as a whole original, at some point in the future, an unscrupulous person will probably be tempted to sell it as a fake.
Left alone, it lives on honestly as what it truly is. A Civil War era percussion rifle that has been shortened & bored out to become a smoothbore. Whether this work was done in the 19th Century by a gunsmith for the local trade, or by some firm like Bannerman's in the 20th Century for the burgeoning, rebirth of muzzleloading here in the United States, to me makes little difference. It was honest work performed by honest tradesmen, for sale to people looking for a honest, low cost shotgun that could get the job done.
I think the gun has a simple beauty, similar to an English shotgun, and probably handles reasonably well.
Edit:
Not every surviving example of a firearm that was manufactured in whatever era, needs to be in pristine condition, nor looking exactly like an original. Honest wear & tear, coupled with the vagaries of whatever man & time has inflicted upon it, is what makes our sport so interesting.
Just like Joe Bonamassa wants all of his road guitars to have a story behind them, instead of being pristine examples that got purchased & stuck under someone's bed for 40-50 years; I think that guns like the one in the OP are far more interesting & important, than a high dollar collector's version of the same gun. ESPECIALLY, if there's a documented story behind it.
Last edited:
Similar threads
