In a house full of guns my wife (5'6" and 130#) has two faves. They're the Lyman Deerstalker (hers is actually 54 cal) and the Pedersoli Frontier Carbine in 50 cal. Truth be known, if it was a 54 cal rather than a 50, I doubt she'd want any other than the Pedersoli. It's lots lighter and easier to shoulder as-is, but she prefers 54 cal for deer.
Another measure, our 12-year old granddaughter is nuts for the Pedersoli, too. She's 5' and real athletic so weight shouldn't be an issue for her. But she likes the balance of the Pedersoli better and certainly shoots it better than the Deerstalker.