• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Building a Mule Ear Lock (Lots of Photos)

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

44-henry

45 Cal.
Joined
Jan 15, 2005
Messages
1,084
Reaction score
144
The other day I was surfing the web, trying to avoid doing anything productive, and I came across a neat little antique New York style mule ear rifle. What I found interesting was that the rifle was very similar in appearance to an antique rifle that I purchased a few years back, with the exception that mine has an A.W. Spies sidehammer on it. I always found the lines of this particular rifle appealing, but never went any further with it until I saw this mule ear. I started imagining what the original builder would have done if a customer had wanted a mule ear style rifle. I figured I would keep the basic elements the same and concentrate on building a lock that would fit the rest of the rifle, so off to the shop I went where I spent the better part of the afternoon avoiding the house chores that needed to be done. I figured some of your might like to see the progress on this project so I took a few pictures along the way.

I started by tracing the original A.W. Spies lockplate on a piece of paper, scanning the image and importing it into AutoCAD where I played around with the location of the slot where the hammer will eventually go. I basically wanted to retain the original shape of the plate, but there are some significant changes to go to this style of lock. I started by grabbing a chunk of 3/8" (1/4" would have been better but I didn't have any) hot rolled steel and tracing the outline of the plate onto the end of the bar. The extra length of the bar gave me something to hold onto while I was cutting out the profile on the vertical bandsaw.

muleear045.jpg


muleear047.jpg


muleear049.jpg


muleear050.jpg


You could certainly use a hacksaw for this, but being essentially a lazy sort of person and having the technology I chose the easy route. You can see from the side view that there is a lot of material to remove.

The rough blank was mounted into the vise of the mill and one side was surfaced.

muleear051.jpg


muleear056.jpg


With one face cleaned up a line was scribed into the edge at .206 and the other side was milled down to the line.

muleear054.jpg


muleear060.jpg


I than transferred the blank to the surface grinder where I ground both faces down to .195. This step wasn't really all that necessary, but I had the grinder available and it only took a couple of minutes to do.

muleear064.jpg


muleear067.jpg


Following this the guidelines for the plate were re-traced using layout dye and the original plate as a template. I C-clamped it in place using a copper shim to protect the original.

muleear073.jpg


The new layout lines can be seen in the photo below.

muleear074.jpg


I felt it was best to cut the slot for the hammer next while the plate was still in the rough form. I chose to go this route since I didn't want to mash the edges of the finished plate in the mill. The slot was layed out using a print of the CAD drawing I created and scribed onto the blank using the boundry lines that were scribed onto the plate earlier. Since the slot does not run parallel to the edges of the plate I used a rotary table another mill to line up the slot parallel to the mills travel and adjusted it using an edge finder until I was satisfied.

muleear085.jpg


muleear087.jpg


The slot was than cut using a 1/4" end mill and staying within the guidelines that were established.

muleear090.jpg


The forward part of the slot goes all the way through the plate; however, there is also a slot that goes only part of the way through the plate that is only visible from the inside. This is where the sear will fit in the finished lock.

muleear093.jpg


The 1/4" cutter leaves a radius that must be removed from the finished slot. I suppose a broach would be ideal for this step, but I chose to do it with a handfile that had one face ground safe. The edges of the slot look a bit fuzzy in the photos, but they are actually pretty clean, I'll do a bit more work on the slot when the hammer is being made.

muleear095.jpg


Following this step the plate was than filed and ground down to the outside guidelines established earlier. I set the table on my disk sander to 3 degrees to cut a slight draft on the plate to help with inletting in the future. Power tools are nice, but some jobs still need to be done by hand with a file which is what I used for the final finishing and shaping.

Here are a couple pictures of the plate as it is right now. The first photos were taken at a slight angle and the plate looks slightly different than the original, it is actually pretty close to the original shape; however, I will refine the forward part a bit more in the final finishing stage.

muleear101.jpg


muleear100.jpg


DSC_0001.jpg


That is about as much as I plan on doing to the plate at this time. The next stage will be to make the hammer and sear.
 
No blueprint, I have seen other mule ear locks and am borrowing some ideas from those, but that's all. I have been drawing it up in CAD to play around with some different ideas and perhaps I'll have some finished technical drawings at the end that I can share if anyone is interested.
 
Well I made it back to the shop today and continued on with the hammer. I thought initially about forging the hammer from thinner stock, but decided to go with a stock removal approach. I happened to have a chunk of 1 1/2" mild steel bar that was left over from a previous project and it seemed a likely candidate for this job. I will be using mild steel for everything on this lock except the springs and the screws which will be made out of 01 and 12L14 respectively. The mild steel will work fine for the main parts since I plan on color casehardening the lock after I've finished inletting it in the stock.

The following pictures show the original chunk of steel, the layout, and finally cutting it off on the bandsaw.

muleearlockstage2007.jpg


muleearlockstage2009.jpg


I suppose a hacksaw would work also, but I'm much too lazy for that approach and find the prospect of that much hacksawing depressing at best.

Though in many ways this lock build is a process of trial and error, I prefer to do most of my mistakes on paper (or CAD) and this is what I have done to determine the final size of the hammer and its relationship to the plate. It probably would have been easier to have left out the notch in the plate until after the hammer was finished, but I was trying to keep as close to the shape of the original lock as possible and did this first. Unfortunately, this made the final shape of the hammer more critical and difficult to do. The next few photos show the AutoCAD program I used to draw up the main elements and also a picture of a print that I produced. If anyone is interested I can provide the file in DXF format and it can be opened on another CAD program (ProgCAD is free and compatable with AutoCAD DXF)

muleearlockstage2024.jpg


muleearlockstage2027.jpg


Once the hammer size was determined a pattern was cut out of paper and will be used to scribe the rough layout lines on the hammer blank after it is trued up on the mill.

muleearlockstage2030.jpg


The blank is surfaced on both faces and the bottom edge in the following photos.

muleearlockstage2031.jpg


muleearlockstage2032.jpg


The hammer nose is lower than the outside edge of the hammer and this is roughed in next on the mill.

muleearlockstage2033.jpg


The exact location of the hammer nose is established using the CAD files for reference and transferring this information to the hammer blank using a digital height gage on a surface plate.

muleearlockstage2034.jpg


muleearlockstage2035.jpg


I decided to use a rotary table to cut the hammer nose. The table must be aligned with the spindle center before this step can be done. I used a headstock center and an edge finder to locate the true center. I

muleearlockstage2036.jpg


The center point scribed on the hammer was carefully aligned with the center/edgefinder in the mill and clamped to the table. Following this the hammer nose was milled in.

muleearlockstage2038.jpg


muleearlockstage2039.jpg


Once this was accomplished the profile was further roughed out on the mill.

muleearlockstage2043.jpg


muleearlockstage2044.jpg


muleearlockstage2045.jpg


As you can see in the above photos there is still lots of material to be removed by filing/grinding to get at the finished shape.

Next the radius on the tumbler end was established using the slot in the plate as a guide. A suitable washer was found in the scrap bin and used to scribe the radius on the hammer blank.

muleearlockstage2046.jpg


After grinding in the radius I checked the fit of the hammer to the plate.

muleearlockstage2048.jpg


muleearlockstage2053.jpg


muleearlockstage2049.jpg


I got lucky and the hammer fit the plate opening pretty good.

I did a bit of preliminary shaping on the hammer with files and you can see the result in the bottom shot.

muleearlockstage2057.jpg


That concludes the work for the day, there is still a lot of shaping to do on the hammer around the nose and of course the sear notches will need to be cut and a slot milled for the hanger. All in all I think it is starting to look like a mule ear.
 
Thanks for sharing your project with the great photo's, it's interesting to watch an idea come to life... :shocked2: You are an inspiration to those of us that would like to start a project like this :bow: , but don't think they have the ability :idunno: , of course, having the machinery and talent helps :thumbsup: !!!!
mgcrumster
 
Thanks for all the replies, I was hoping to get the sear and spring made today, but ended up doing other things instead.

I wouldn't let the lack of elaborate machine tools stop you from doing something like this. A hacksaw and files would work in place of the bandsaw and mill and some parts, like the hammer, could be greatly simplified by using thinner stock and bending to the right curvature.
 
You are doing such a fine job, I am shy to suggest anything, however, the hammer could me cut from a piece of thick angle steel.
WE NEEEEED MORE PHOTOS!
Great work! Always wanted a " Mule Ear Rifle"
I missed one a few days ago on Gun Broker.
All the best
Old Ford
 
That is a good idea about using the angle iron, I'll definitely look into that if I make another one of these locks. Many of the originals that I have seen actually appear to have relatively shallow hammers and some also appear to be a two piece construction, so there would be a lot of construction possiblities.
 
Looks like your doing a great job, keep it up.
Here's one I made about 10 years back for a T/C. It has a bell crank to work the sear so the original set trigger could be used.
muleear3.jpg
 
Back
Top