I'd have to hold one in my hands to offer final judgement. I've got my eye open for a short gun, but the first priority is that the center of gravity fall right between my hands.
I don't want it to replace my GPR, but it in addition to it for better handling in hunts featuring fast shots in close quarters. The GPR is terrific for more deliberate shooting and longer offhand shots due to its forward center of gravity, but it's pretty slow to swing and shoot when speed counts. Shorter guns with a more centered COG has proven much more useful in close quarters.
My mind had been running toward the Lyman Deerstalker, but others would do if they met my COG criteria. At $235 from Midsouth, it will be hard to beat the Lyman for price, and I can sure testify for quality in the other Lyman rifles I own. If the Cabelas was more than that, I'd have a hard look at the Lyman while you're kicking the idea around.