I've thought on this long and hard myself. Unless you have a mentor you have to rely on what you read, what you can figure out yourself, and what you learn from your mistakes. Then, there are the tricks and having an eye for lines that only come with repeated practice and examining many firearms of a given style in 3-D.
I figure a gunsmith who has made 25 or 30 guns of a specific "school" has made all his mistakes and learned all the little quirks of that pattern. I'd rather pay him for one gun than make five myself that I'm not quite satisfied with before I "get good" at it.
The investment in tools and books to make a carved & engraved rifle is also considerable. It certainly does not justify a single project. Most tools can be used for many other wood and metal projects, so I won't say tools are a poor investment. But they are an investment none the less.
If you want the hobby/passtime/skill of building flintlocks then start gathering goodies. If you want the lifestyle of hunting the skills of shooting and trekking or reenacting you might be farther ahead with a gun built by a pro.
I would LOVE to be able to turn out fine flintlocks. I just have too much else going on to devote the time to learning. I don't see me ever owning more than three at once, anyway.
I figure a gunsmith who has made 25 or 30 guns of a specific "school" has made all his mistakes and learned all the little quirks of that pattern. I'd rather pay him for one gun than make five myself that I'm not quite satisfied with before I "get good" at it.
The investment in tools and books to make a carved & engraved rifle is also considerable. It certainly does not justify a single project. Most tools can be used for many other wood and metal projects, so I won't say tools are a poor investment. But they are an investment none the less.
If you want the hobby/passtime/skill of building flintlocks then start gathering goodies. If you want the lifestyle of hunting the skills of shooting and trekking or reenacting you might be farther ahead with a gun built by a pro.
I would LOVE to be able to turn out fine flintlocks. I just have too much else going on to devote the time to learning. I don't see me ever owning more than three at once, anyway.