• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Eighteenth Century Stitching – Part One Make a hole

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

thecapgunkid

40 Cal.
Joined
Oct 9, 2014
Messages
342
Reaction score
6
EIGHTEENTH CENTURY STITCHING ”“ PART ONE Make a hole. The awl
This series of posts is to help craftsmen in making their leather stitching more authentic. The appearance of hunting bags, bullet bags, wallets , pouches, sheaths and so on will show a marked difference when this technique is used. It differs from modern leatherworking techniques in that;
Ӣ The stitches are smaller and tighter than those taught out of current craft manuals
Ӣ The holes are smaller than those made by rotary punches
Ӣ Needles, or bristles, used are considerably smaller than those used in modern stitching
Ӣ The thread is a different texture, substance and color that that used in the modern way (including artificial sinew)
Once a craftsman starts stitching in this historical technique, the work produced will have a distinctly different look. Once gotten used to as a practice, it will be hard to go back to pre-waxed thread, hole punchers and large harness needles.

A straight awl used to make holes is most often referred to as a “Stabbing” Awl in shoemaking and harness trades. You can find handle with the bottle shape and knob at the end all over, but I bought most of mine at flea markets. Chuck bits for blades are OK if you want to spend the money, but are not necessary. You can insert an awl blade in a good handle by mounting the blade point down in a vice near the base of the blade. By drilling or using a smaller hole than blade diameter, a good friction fit can be obtained. Sissies can epoxy the blades if they choose.
The idea behind most professional 18th century stitching was to use two bristles, a clamp and one of these awls which was generally not put down while finishing the stitch line to close a seam. We will use needles because bristles can be hard to find.
To get a good fit and feel with your awl wrap your ring finger around the neck formed by the button at the base of the awl and hold it in your palm while working the needles. I have always found that the best size awl is one you can determine. Lay the awl handle across your palm and wrap your ring finger around the neck. The end where you insert the blade should be either at the end of your palm between the index finger and base of your thumb or about a half inch beyond that. The former ( smaller) for stitching softer leather such as deerskin or calf or light weight cow and the latter (larger) for the harder, stiffer and thicker leather you may be working with.
I will always take a straight blade for my awls and stone it so that there is a diamond cross section shape to the entire shank, starting very delicately at the tip and gradually tapering outward to the end that is inserted into the handle. Try not to use rounded blades most often seen off the shelf at retail. If the blade you buy is diamond shaped but seems to taper or even bulge a little just aft of the tip, straighten it out so that the taper to the blade is gradual and straight. Don’t compromise here. Just do it and work patiently. Emery, stone, crocus cloth in that order.
Ideally, the point of the awl should look so fragile as to break if you look at it hard. The taper allows you to adjust the size of the hole it stabs depending on how deeply you stab the awl into the hole you are making.
No matter what you do from here, whether you read these posts or not, polish the awl blade. Take your time and make sure the blade is slick for its entire length. This will make all the difference you need to prevent having to force and muscle the hole you are stabbing. Trust me on this”¦it makes a huge difference in your finished work. You can’t work accurately if you are forcing the job.
If you are stitching in a clamp, when stabbing brace the other side of the piece with your index finger and thumb tips, staying out of the way of the sharp tip of the awl. If you’re working on your lap without a clamp, brace the opposite side of the piece with the inside pads of you index finger and middle finger, keeping both out of the way of the moving awl.
You always want to strive to stab straight in and straight out, evenly and at ninety degrees to your leather surface, without having to twist or force the awl. If you have to force the awl, your blade is wrong. When the awl glides easily in and out, you know your awl and your hand-eye are all working together.
When you stab, with or without the clamp, try to follow one rule. The cross sectioned length of your diamond shaped blade should always be at 90 degrees to the edge of the leather. If it is parallel to the edge of the leather, your stitches won’t be as tight or pleasing. You’ll see too much hole. This is a fine point and detail you have to see for yourself. We will cover it more in subsequent posts.
It is the combination of handle shape, taper and polish that turns your awl from something off the shelf to something uniquely personal in your work. You will learn to prize this tool. If I am parking it on my shoe bench, I have a drilled wood block to house it and other sharp tools and awls. If placed in my tool box or in a drawer, I block off the tip with some cork to keep it from breaking.
We’ll talk about curved awls later
IN the meantime, head over to photobucket.com and enter the http below.
Holdingtheawl_zps982f068b.jpg.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Great post Greg. As someone with western bootmaking experience, your info is right on. Took some practice to learn but once you do, people start asking you "what kind of machine did you sew that on?" and when you tell them it's handsewn they don't believe you! I also learned a lot from Al Stohlman's books. "The Art of Handsewing Leather" is a good place to start. My bootmaking teacher once told me "your awl should be scary sharp, so sharp that it's halfway thru your finger before you know it". He was right!
 
Thanks, clyde. Kinda sorta hang around for the next few posts iffn you don't mind. More pics for me to screw up.
 
draw a horizontal line on a piece of paper. This represents the top edge of your seam. Right under it, draw a row of diamonds standing up. Then draw another lying down.

I'll put a visual in a later post.
 
newtewsmoke said:
Greg Geiger said:
The cross sectioned length of your diamond shaped blade should always be at 90 degrees to the edge of the leather.
i cant quite visualize which way you mean
From Al Stohlman's book "The Art of Handsewing Leather"
awl_holes.jpg


A big aid for keeping the awl for keeling the awl holes correctly in line are pricking irons, which are unfortunately not cheap, but are well worth it if you want your stitching to improve...
 
Very interesting and very informative. :thumbsup: Thanks for sharing. I'm looking forward to more.
 
Only big thing I differ with you on is the shape of the handle. I like the general shape you demo,but I want a flat on one side, if not two, with the flats oriented the same as the diamond cross-section of the blade.

That does two things. The flats keep the blooming thing from rolling off the bench when I get careless and lay it down. Cement floors have ruined many an awl blade. :redface:

The orientation of the flats in relation to the shape of the blade really help in keeping your awl oriented correctly to the edge of the leather. I can do it by feel, helping me pay attention when I should be.

Great write-up. Looking forward to more, as I bet lots of folks are.
 
I follow Stohlman's orientation, too, LaBonte. Never had a problem with leather tears in doing so, even with thin leather. Amen to the pricking irons, too.

One thing I'll add:

I think it was Wick that spelled out an "over and under" orientation for the needles and threads on pass-throughs. That cleaned up my stitches more than anything else, and produces a really strait seam even with the holes oriented ala Stohlman. If I could dredge that thread up, I'd recommend it to Claude for a sticky in this section.

This one's headed that direction too, I think.
 
Not to steel the thunder of the OP anyone who prefers visuals i.e. videos should check out Nigel Armitage's video channel on youtube http://www.youtube.com/user/Nordicbadger

Bear - what Wick was mentioning is a kind of a "flip" of the threads before pulling tight - more of an English saddlery method than the American method as taught by Stohlman where in the threads are "straighter" while stitching and then smoothed with a stitching wheel - a method based on the Spanish style of the Southwest. For Eastern Colonial and later Eastern American the English method would be the more common and is what the OP is discussing. I've learned both over the years and use what is appropriate for the time and place when sewing historical goods.

PS Nigel shows both methods - using pricking irons as well as an overstitch wheel
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Geez. I don't recall that, and am not sure of what either of you mean. :redface: Either of you know more of leather craft than I do, or ever likely will.
 
Wick Ellerbe said:
Geez. I don't recall that, and am not sure of what either of you mean.

Shows you how well I don't explain myself! :rotf:

You (or whoever is hiding in my fuzzy memory) talked about consistently raising or pulling up a little on the first thread once it's through the hole, then passing the second needle under that as it starts its own pass, pulling down a little on that that thread as you tighten.

It really helps keep the orientation the same with each successive stitch. They look great as-is, or you can run your overstitch wheel over the finished seam to further align the stitches.

If not you, dunno who it was. But I sure associate your great stitch work with that technique.

One observation:

A guy will learn the difference between a staking wheel and an overstitch wheel in one big hurry, if he runs the staking wheel over his finished stitching. Don't ask how I learned that lesson! :redface:
 
Well, that's the way I stitch, but don't remember posting about it, but then I don't remember as well as I once did. I greatly appreciate your compliment on my stitching, but I am afraid it is undeserved. I drill my stitch holes with a 5/64" bit in my drill press. I then use a groover to keep the stitching straighter. I never intended to do as much leather work as I have ended up doing, and never thought my work would be in any degree of demand, so never approached it as seriously as I may should have.
 
Wick Ellerbe said:
I drill my stitch holes with a 5/64" bit in my drill press.

Huh....

I don't remember that at all, so dunno.

In any case, hats off for your finished products, both in metal and leather! :hatsoff:
 
Interesting stuff. I use a grooving tool to make a straight groove along the edge, set in maybe 1/8". I then use the overstitch wheel to space out the hole locations. This doesn't make any holes- it just indents the leather, it's the same tool I use at the end to pack down the finished stitches. Then I use a round awl to make the holes but will switch to a diamond awl and angle them as Chuck shows. I use Tandy linen thread. I "shoelace" that is- put a needle on either end and make a solid line of stitches on both sides. At the end I back stitch 2 1/2 spaces and cut the excess on the back side (the cut off ends are both on the back). Finally I use the over stitch wheel to pack down and clean up the stitches.
Until now I just didn't consider whether these tools are or are not pc. Was there any common number of stitches per inch used pre-1840? How close to the edge was most stitching? Today's linen thread has a certain twist to the fibers, is this pc?
I'm always learning....one reason muzzle loading is a life time pursuit.
 
Back
Top