This is my Colonial in .54 stocked in cherry. I was convinced I needed a brass patchbox, so I went ahead and took my best swing at it. I was regretting that decision about 4 hours into the process, but now that it's finished, I like it and I'm glad I did it.
I initially wanted to do the dark lye staining and rust browning, but after seeing what light colored cherry looks like I changed direction. I did use some lye, but the mixture was very light. What I actually used was 3 .45-70 cases of lye in a 1lb hodgdon powder jug filed with water. Then I used 2 heavy coats of Watco natural Danish oil. Once that dried, I applied half a dozen coats of Arrow wood finish.
I had already tried browning the metal, but I didn't like the glossy red "candied" look; so I stripped it off with blue and rust remover. The resulting gray looked nice to me so I left it at that.
I initially wanted to do the dark lye staining and rust browning, but after seeing what light colored cherry looks like I changed direction. I did use some lye, but the mixture was very light. What I actually used was 3 .45-70 cases of lye in a 1lb hodgdon powder jug filed with water. Then I used 2 heavy coats of Watco natural Danish oil. Once that dried, I applied half a dozen coats of Arrow wood finish.
I had already tried browning the metal, but I didn't like the glossy red "candied" look; so I stripped it off with blue and rust remover. The resulting gray looked nice to me so I left it at that.