i, too, use plain old beeswax. (if you don't have a source, contact your Ag extension agent and ask for the name and phone number of a local beekeeper ... they'll be happy to help .. the beekeeper will probably be willing to sell you a lifetime supply of beeswax- it need not be refined, strained or whatever).
having said that, Makeumsmoke's stuff from the Frankfort Arsenal really does seem to produce a great result.
when you cast (if you're not already doing so) make sure that you are wearing long sleeved shirt and trousers. wear 'proper' shoes (i.e. not sandals) and be sure to cast outdoors. you want to have the wind at your back, so the fumes blow away from you. of course, don't eat or drink anything while casting, and be sure to wash yor hands thoroughly after you're done. i wear a hat when i cast, especially in the warmer month: one drop of sweat falling into the molten lead will instantly and explosively turn to steam and splash lead in all directions from a surprising distance. very very bad ju- ju.
fumes and accidential ingestion of lead can mess you up- not trying to scare you, but it is something you should know about so that you can take proper precautions, like rolling up your windows in a rainstorm.
once you've cast your own roundball, you will be officially turned to the darkside. enjoy!
make good smoke!