You forgot to mention something with your "pry and pray" method.
I didn't see anything about all of the scratches and scrapes that prying will leave on the face of the lockplate. :hmm:
To the OP:
Carefully examine the tumbler for the little tiny fly that locks often have.
It is the small part that blocks off the half cock notch.
The fly is often held onto the tumbler by the bridging "bridle" but on some locks, it is located next to the lockplate.
These locks that locate the tumbler next to the lockplate make removing the fly impossible until the tumbler is driven out of the hammer.
With the lockplate laying with the hammer on top while it rests on the two supports, you can't see the fly (it and the tumbler are under the lockplate). When the tumbler becomes loose, the fly usually takes the opportunity to escape to places unknown.
Putting a blob of grease on the tumbler before driving the tumbler out can keep it from escaping.
Of course, this only applies to the few locks that have located their fly between the tumbler and the lock plate.
I usually stick the fly onto a piece of masking tape when it's removed.
That keeps it from escaping and the tape is easy to find when it's time to put the lock back together.