Use PB at the shop, because it's fast..get good color I can touch it up. Cleanliness is critical. I have a helper with a second propane torch and
a non contact thermometer to judge temperature. Put it on with long strokes of a wet cotton pad. Don't get impatient.
When I can I abrasive blast the steel and acetone wash before using PB.
Laurel Mountain takes longer..
Just FYI: some steels have alloying elements that resist browning.
I had a customer want his modern cowboy double side by side browned. I stripped the blue. Tried Laurel Mountain, as I did not want to put the torch
to the barrels. Nothing happened.
Realized the bbls were chrome moly.
Chrome was preventing browning.
So, painted the bbl with a dilute solution of nitric acid in alcohol, and let it sit overnight.
Next day, bbls were green! That was the chrome etched out of the surface!
Cleaned the bbls of chrome, without burnishing with steel wool.
Then Laurel Mountain browned the bbl very nicely in several coats with usual carding in between.
Neutralized finish with baking soda, and then oil soaked.
Still looks good 18yrs later...customer is a regular.