My experience says that the Alox works just fine in muzzleloaders but I wipe my bore between shots. However, given a choice between Alox and a heavy grease such as bees wax with olive oil, I, too, will take the grease over the Alox. He asked "will it work?" and, yes it will work but, like you, I don't think it is the best lube to use. I use it on my pistol bullets but I also use just a small dab of Crisco over each bullet. I don't fill the chamber to the top, just a small dab in each chamber.