If you like light colored maple go with it, also, don't think for a minute just because it is not a standard finish today that it wasn't used in the old days. In fact, many knowledgable folks have concluded that many early American firearms were never actually stained, many might have just been used after the rough scraping was accomplished. Over time they have developed a dark patina, but that doesn't mean they started out life that way. Even if they were given a finish, a lot of time it might not have ammounted to much more than an acid stain and a beeswax rub. If the acid was weak, or had other elements disolved in it it could have produced a lighter shade. It pays to remember that today we do this hobby as just that, a hobby, but remember that the people we try to emulate were doing this to earn a living. A sound stock, lock and barrel was the gun, the rest of it within reason was just icing on the cake and not too many people could afford all the nicities that we today take for granted. One thing you can be sure of, today's crop of rifles turned out by modern day gunsmiths probably would be the envy of most of our counterparts 200 years ago.