Getting a reply from me directly has surprised a few people, even people who know me moderately well. I take it as a compliment that people think our organization is much larger than it is.
Thank you for the kind words about the magazine, as I said above it is a labor of love for me. I was introduced to MUZZLELOADER in September of 1995 by a family friend, I immediately subscribed (I was 16, I asked my grandmother to get me a subscription). In 2007 when Bill Scurlock asked if I would be interested in taking over the magazine when he and Linda were ready to retire, I was dumbfounded. I consider it a huge honor to be part of the legacy of the magazine.
While I stand behind my editorial from 2010, and believe it is still valid, I was wrong about the hobby shrinking and aging. On Facebook there are groups dedicated to aspects of our sport with thousands of members, the Hershel House School group has over 35,000, the CLA Group has almost 20,000, there is a rendezvous and living history trader group that has around 15,000-20,000 (I am too lazy to check the number right now). But these interested parties don't seem to be joining groups, I believe the NMLRA only has around 12,000 members, the CLA has around 1,500, and we has around 8,500 subscribers (while our own Facebook page has 15,000 followers).
I don't believe the hobby is shrinking, or aging, but it is definitely changing. The younger people I see involved are usually either into very authentic living history, or the artisan side of things and making items. I also believe the hobby is more spread out than it ever used to be. 30 years ago there was a dozen or so large events that everyone tried to get to, now there is something going on almost every weekend of the year. I can think of at least 2 living history events going on right now, and there would have been a 3rd had the club not had issues with the landowner. So the bigger events have gotten smaller, and there are many, many more smaller events going on. Add to that the internet, where you don't really need to go to an event to purchase needed supplies and I think that's changed things as well. Those are just my observations...