• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Need Help Finalizing VA Rifle

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

SawTooth

32 Cal
Joined
Feb 11, 2011
Messages
42
Reaction score
0
Hello Everyone,

I recently came to the embarrassing discovery that a .50 Cal Pure Lead Cast Ball weighing in at approx 180 gr is a “Tad” lighter than one of them other zip gun projectiles that I been using on big game, (Deer, Black Bear, Elk), so I figured I’d ask for a little direction here.

The TVM Flint VA .50 that I have in the pipeline has a Rice Swamped 38x50 B Wt. Sq. Cut Rifling weighing in at 3.11 lbs.

With the above info, bbl specs, member input and the “discovery” I am thinkin’ that a better move might be to go with a Rice Swamped 38x54 C Wt. bbl Sq. Cut Rifling, weighing in at 4.3 lbs.

Though this will mean a pound or so more to lug thru the woods, that .54 220 gr PRB means more weight/penetration all else being equal lock/charge wise.

Yes, I understand that there could be some minor handling differences weight wise which could make a difference while hunting on the ground. While in a tree stand the difference is sure to be negligible, ok.

BUT WAIT”¦

At 4.3 lbs bbl weight for the .54 Cal you could also go with a TVM Rice .62/20ga Smoothbore Rifle much like that one I’ve seen RoundBall runnin’ the woods with.

According to the bbl manufacturer the same 38” swamped profile (Transition Series / Early American) in a Smoothbore is gonna come in at approx 4.4 lbs.

The weight difference between the .54 Rifle bbl and the .62/20ga smoothbore bbl is negligible though I am not sure about handling differences.

For me, the Smooth Rifle’s load versatility opens up turkeys, small game, buck n ball hogs, and a 350 gr PRB for big game.

I do think that the wide butt on the TVM VA platform will absorb the additional recoil of the .54 Rifle or the .62/20ga Smoothbore just fine.

I also feel that if chosen in Smooth Rifle form, it will group out to 75 yards with a PRB once I get rollin’ with a flinter. Max for me in .50 or .54 flint is 100yds.

So here I am at a cross roads”¦ .54 Rifle or go with a .62/20 Smooth Rifle?

Any help with the decision welcomed!

Thanks,

SawTooth
 
Just me, but I'd get the .54. If you will use it as your big game rifle (deer, elk, etc) that would make more sense. If you really intend to use it for small game as well, then the .62 would be a fine choice - recognizing a bit of range you'd give up.
 
Thanks Hanshi and Others,

Looks like I'm Buyin' Both!

.54 Rifle (C Wt)
.62 Smooth Rifle (D Wt)

SawTooth
 

Latest posts

Back
Top