Reply to thread

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Message

A caution using vinegar. I have been restoring antique woodworking tools for almost 20 years, off and on. I used vinegar a few times to remove rust from modern tools, But fairly early on I ruined a lovely ancient draw knife by leaving it in a vinegar solution too long. My mistake, a lapse of attention due to other stuff going on. The cutting surface was so badly pitted it was ruined. The softer wrought iron less so, but still obvious pits. I never used vinegar again to remove rust and switched to more forgiving methods.

Today I use Kroil and abrasives, sometimes Evaporust and abrasives such as Scotchbrite and fine sandpaper. Large flat surfaces like handsaws get scraped with a razor blade with the edges rounded to avoid scratches, then a fine sanding with a block backer and lubricated paper to let you read the etching for the first time in 100 years. Very satisfying to restore a fine old (insert your favorite tool here) back to useful life.

<blockquote data-quote="rp77469" data-source="post: 2713445" data-attributes="member: 5346">A caution using vinegar.&nbsp; I have been restoring antique woodworking tools for almost 20 years, off and on.&nbsp; I used vinegar a few times to remove rust from modern tools,&nbsp; But fairly early on I ruined a lovely ancient draw knife by leaving it in a vinegar solution too long.&nbsp; My mistake, a lapse of attention due to other stuff going on.&nbsp; The cutting surface was so badly pitted it was ruined.&nbsp; The softer wrought iron less so, but still obvious pits.&nbsp; I never used vinegar again to remove rust and switched to more forgiving methods.&nbsp; Today I use Kroil and abrasives, sometimes Evaporust and abrasives such as Scotchbrite and fine sandpaper.&nbsp; Large flat surfaces like handsaws get scraped with a razor blade with the edges rounded to avoid scratches, then a fine sanding with a block backer and lubricated paper to let you read the etching for the first time in 100 years.&nbsp; Very satisfying to restore a fine old (insert your favorite tool here) back to useful life.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="rp77469, post: 2713445, member: 5346"] A caution using vinegar. I have been restoring antique woodworking tools for almost 20 years, off and on. I used vinegar a few times to remove rust from modern tools, But fairly early on I ruined a lovely ancient draw knife by leaving it in a vinegar solution too long. My mistake, a lapse of attention due to other stuff going on. The cutting surface was so badly pitted it was ruined. The softer wrought iron less so, but still obvious pits. I never used vinegar again to remove rust and switched to more forgiving methods. Today I use Kroil and abrasives, sometimes Evaporust and abrasives such as Scotchbrite and fine sandpaper. Large flat surfaces like handsaws get scraped with a razor blade with the edges rounded to avoid scratches, then a fine sanding with a block backer and lubricated paper to let you read the etching for the first time in 100 years. Very satisfying to restore a fine old (insert your favorite tool here) back to useful life. [/QUOTE]

Verification