• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Newbie to MLF with a new pistol So beautiful I'm reluctant to fire it

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Aug 25, 2022
Messages
70
Reaction score
57
Location
West Michigan
Hello gents, always wanted one of these highly engraved numbers. At auction, it was listed as used but I'm pretty sure it's NOS. Pietta 44. 1998 date code. Noticed fine metal dust during initial cleaning. Must be unfired due to the pristine cylinder chambers, hammer channel (?) and nipples -- I don't think these could be so well cleaned after usage, but I may be wrong. Looks like it was dry-fired some, though. I'm not knowledgeable enough to tune it up like ya'll do. Tempted to just display it.
 

Attachments

  • Pietta 1.jpeg
    Pietta 1.jpeg
    529.5 KB
  • Pietta 3 Cylinder.jpeg
    Pietta 3 Cylinder.jpeg
    98.4 KB
  • Pietta 6.jpeg
    Pietta 6.jpeg
    121.8 KB
  • Pietta 5.jpeg
    Pietta 5.jpeg
    68.4 KB
  • Pietta 2.jpeg
    Pietta 2.jpeg
    90.9 KB
There is no cure, the only treatment possible is to get out this very day and fire it with that old dirty black powder. Then you will appreciate the gun as it is a bunch more! You can clean it as good as ya want....to where not many would ever be able to tell it was fired. Let us know, we care.
 
Hello gents, always wanted one of these highly engraved numbers. At auction, it was listed as used but I'm pretty sure it's NOS. Pietta 44. 1998 date code. Noticed fine metal dust during initial cleaning. Must be unfired due to the pristine cylinder chambers, hammer channel (?) and nipples -- I don't think these could be so well cleaned after usage, but I may be wrong. Looks like it was dry-fired some, though. I'm not knowledgeable enough to tune it up like ya'll do. Tempted to just display it.
If you keep it mint, you'll just have to re-sell in future and we can't take stuff with us! Eccch, imagine dry firing a perc. revolver! Good luck whatever you decide!
 
I fire everything. Once bought from an old boss (as a deal that he could buy back later on first dibbs for same price of $65.00) a Chief Crazy Horse Commemorative 30-30. Thing shot a hell of a group. He fired me?

He also fired me for farting (twice), getting an elk tag and insisting on taking the PTO scheduled 6 mo earlier and the final time cause I had strep and wouldn't go duck hunting with him after working all night. God I miss those ol days

Still a REAL CLOSE friend too lol.
 
It's already been dry fired a lot. The hammer face and nipples have met many times!! The cyl notches have gouges in the approaches (excessive spring tension). I doubt you can fit caps on the nipples. That being the case, SHOOT IT !!! LOL
btw, it has a short arbor too (1998)

Mike
 
I had just made a trade at the Missoula gun show years ago for a brand new in the box 2nd. gen Colt SAA made in 1957. I had a table and the table next to me was a friend of mine. He is a gun engraver and does beautiful professional work. Well we're sitting there admiring the beautiful 7 1/2" 45 and he says to me hey, when we gonna shoot that Colt, and I say were not I'm puttin this one in the closet, it's too nice to shoot. So he looks at me an says"who you savin it for you old coot?" I shoulda listened to him and shot it as I saved it alright and less than a year later let it slip thru my greasy paws in a dump trade.
 
Hello gents, always wanted one of these highly engraved numbers. At auction, it was listed as used but I'm pretty sure it's NOS. Pietta 44. 1998 date code. Noticed fine metal dust during initial cleaning. Must be unfired due to the pristine cylinder chambers, hammer channel (?) and nipples -- I don't think these could be so well cleaned after usage, but I may be wrong. Looks like it was dry-fired some, though. I'm not knowledgeable enough to tune it up like ya'll do. Tempted to just display it.
It's a fantasy gun, just load it up and shoot it like any other.
 
What ever that cylinder is plated with, doubt it’s brass, is going to be effected by the hot gases and gun powder residue. Guaranteed it’s not going to remain pristine. On brass frame revolvers it’s character on that cylinder tacky.

Having said that I’d be inclined to obtain a plain Jane cylinder for shooting saving the “gold” for display. The frame and barrell will clean up.
 
Fired nine rounds last evening. Two fizzles (no squibs) , two hang fires. 24 Gr Pyrodex P and RWS 1075 primers. Going to swap out the nipples for the Slixshots that are touted so often here -- to your point Cynthialee. Also its is a brass frame as you suspected, Robert. Need to get my head around this arbor business. I'd never heard of that until recently as I have gotten back into BP. Is that the same thing as the cylinder pin? Thanks again for the friendly input everyone.
 
Back
Top