Leatherbark said:
I tried all sorts of wads under a .600 ball with patch...........I couldnt help to believe that the wad caused fliers occasionally that I didnt get with just a patched ball. But you never know that maybe the gasses acting against a patched ball with maybe a crooked crown might act differntly if a wad is used.................Bob
I've proven to myself over many years now that every high power PRB or conical hunting load I've used in .45/.50/.54/.58/.62cal rifles are improved with the use of Oxyoke prelubed wool wads over the powder.
So naturally, when I began experimenting with PRB loads in a .62cal smoothbore, and then a .54cal smoothbore, I used Oxyoke wads over powder. I then spent several range trips, many powder charges, different size balls, different thickness patches, etc, and I could not eliminate a wild flyer every 5-7 shots. One day at the range after the last failed test of anything else I knew to try, I sat down in utter disbelief going over and over everything I had changed...what else could there possibly be.
Then in pure desperation...because I KNEW Oxyoke wonderwads had been golden for me for years and never caused any problems...I said what the heck and shot a group without a wad...no flyers.
Shot another group, no flyers.
Shot a 3rd group, no flyers.
Hey, can this possibly be...shot another group WITH wads and had 2 flyers out of 5.
Shot another group WITHOUT wads and no flyers.
Next weekend ran the same tests with the .54cal and had the same results. No question the OP wad was the culprit for me.
In then wondering why, I thought maybe gas was prematurely blowing out along one side and tilting things at muzzle exit, so I tried to eliminate that by using 2, then 3 wads stacked on each other but I still got flyers. So I don't know what it is but when I use prelubed Oxyoke OP wads in my GM .62 & .54cal Flint smoothbore barrels, I get flyers.
The good news is that a well lubed patch works fine in both smoothbores without a wad so it's become a non-issue...but I do wish I knew exactly what the failure mechanism is.