Like I said, it is all in the "Druthers". If something doesn't appeal to me on the rifle, I seldom replicate it, be it a patchbox, carving, engraving, etc. Some guys build them Exactly like the originals, I don't do that because I seldom see an original that I like Everything on the rifle.
Now that last rifle in the Bucks section of RCA 1 is the Bucks I like the best. Of all of them, that one appeals to me the most & fits me well & etc. The rifles I have made similar to it had Really nice wood & when I laid the patchbox on them, For Me, it took away from the rifle so I left it off.
Now some will say "Oh, you can't do that, that is what makes it a Bucks." Well, I did & it is still a Bucks !! :haha:
One the same token, if that rifle with that patchbox appeals to you, then you should by all means put it on there.
.050 should be adequate for the patchbox lid. The patchbox I made like that was a 2 piece one. I made the hinge out of some .035 and a SS wire thru the hinge & then I was going to soft soldered the hinge to the lid. I had it all made & ready but never soldered it on cause I decided not to use it. The store bought patchbox kits I looked at for that particular rifle were made the same way. :thumbsup: