Hi Darkhorse;
I liked the inletting, and the wood from Pecatonica very much. I don't have a lot of tooling and my Early Lancaster was the first I'd ever built, although I've looked at hundreds of other fellows rifles. I did my work with only an exacto knife, a couple of pocket knives, a rasp, a couple of files, and a few home-made tools from old screwdrivers that I ground down. Their inletting was close enough that I didn't have any problems and like I said, I'm not even GOOD!
I have heard that Pecatonica makes stocks for many other retailers. I don't suppose that they would admit to it for concern of angering their retailers. I do think that Pecatonica delivers to you a wood quality that is a little above what the others might grade it at. I built my Early Lancaster with the Grade 2 wood. I think Grade 1 is 0 to 30% curl, Grade 2 is 30 to 60% if memory serves correctly. My stock is very nice.
Pecatonica charges $80 for a grade one stock, and $100 for a grade 2. Inletting is $42.50. The dovetails are cut for $5 each. They will cut for the buttplate if you don't have a lot of tools (like I don't). They will cut the barrel to a shorter length for $5.
When you call, Dick Greensides owns the business. Jeff is the helper. Jeff is definitely more talkative than Dick. I think that Jeff does most of the cutting as Dick is in his 70's.
They're both really nice guys.
They will cut barrel sizes and inlet stocks for other than what their catalogue shows. They seem pretty willing to accomodate. I think that they now inlet 98% for all their styles, although their catalogue doesn't state this.
My opinion is that the only thing that Pecatonica is lousy at is designing a catalogue and a website. I guess they're more about their product than about marketing their product.
All in all, I plan on doing business with them again. I'd just like to figure out what their "Pre-Revolutionary" rifle looks like before I would order one.
My area, and therefore my chosen personna is about the late 1760's in Southwestern Pennsylvania. I'm an early settler type. This leaves out a lot of the later "Golden Age" era, post-Revolutionary rifles. The Jaegers, the Transitionals, the Tulles, the Northwest guns, and the plainer Fowlers would work, but I'm trying to stretch to get an "early longrifle" that's not quite as heavy and will have at least a little thinner lines.
Regards,
Ironsights Jerry.