I'm not sure what to make of it. For sure, almost everything has gotten more expensive. However, there is something else going on with muzzleloader parts. Personally, I think a lot of the critical components come from only a few sources. I heard the Allen Foundry ceased production several years ago. This really hurt. You cannot get a Hawken style breechplug and tang for a 1-1/8" barrel any more, nor can you get a Hawken-type solid patent breech, as the Hawken shop used on their full stocked rifles. You cannot get a J&S styled trigger guard, with the big bow and circular scroll. Fortunately, there do seem to be Hawken hook breeches for 1" barrels, and a couple of the later-styled Hawken guards. However, we have lost a lot of the variety. I believe Davis locks were assembled from components originating from the Mould & Gun Shop, but I don't know the status of that outfit.
I would disagree with those who maintain the demand is not there. I think there is plenty of demand. The fact that someone can get $250 for a Siler lock tells us there is demand. Has anybody priced Laubach locks recently?
I wish some enterprising fellow or small consortium would resurrect the Allen Foundry and resume making the former product line at the expected level of quality. This would have far-reaching, positive consequences. It would be a great day if someone would re-open North Star West, also. I think they tried to sell the business, but there were no takers. Danny Caywood is also making some noise about retiring, but as far as I know, nobody has offered to take over his business, either.
I believe there is plenty of demand. Why else would there be 2-5 year waits for custom guns, or flint locks selling for $250 and up? We just don't have enough manufacturers.
Back in the frontier days, a good rifle was a major purchase, along the lines of buying a new car nowadays. I think a lot of us have gotten spoiled by a decades-long run of affordable muzzleloaders. I think we may have to become more selective now, and be willing to pay for the quality we demand.
I sure do appreciate what Jim Kibler is doing. A lot of us do. He looks like he has a lot of good years left in him, but I hope he considers training an apprentice or protege or two, to step in when Jim wants a vacation, and to continue the business when he's ready to retire. I also appreciate
@Eric Krewson 's post, which suggests there are some supplies out there if you know where to look.
Best regards,
Notchy Bob