S or flat guard? work in progress

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Joe Yanta

45 Cal.
Joined
Sep 13, 2004
Messages
514
Reaction score
12
Work in progress. Ready to heat treat. I have have been debating between a flat guard or "S" guard for this knife. What is your opinion? or maybe no guard?

9" blade from 1/4" 1095

IMG_0809.jpg


I've got a week to think about it. I'll finish it up next weekend.

Joe
 
Joe :

I'd do the "S" guard , just give the knife a little flair .. keep in mind its just my 2 cents .........
 
I second that Joe. An "S" guard would look good with that piece of horn...Bud

P.S. good to hear from ya again...
 
I would shorten the top arm to about half its height. Its not really needed, as you are not going to use this for knife fighting, really, and the bottom arm of the guard will protect your fingers from getting out onto that blade. a little asymetry would make that knife look good. You already have some asymetry in the butt of the handle.
 
I like your ideas :) I'll shorten the top bar and put a slight curve forward. How about keeping the bottom bar straight for about a third to half its length and then a little more curve to the rear?

What y'all think?

Joe
 
I like your idea, Joe. I would also lengthen the choil, or finger cut on the back of the blade just in front of the lower guard arm, so it is wide enough to allow you to wrap your index finger through the cut out, and in front of the guard, to help give you control when you are working with the knife actually cutting, or skinning an animal. This grip is particularly useful with your hands are bloody, because the guard will allow you to lock the knife between your index finger and the middle finger- your two strongest fingers- so that you maintain control no matter what.

The knives I love to make, and look at are usually asymetrical, either in the blade, the handle or both. I make my handles wider at the top, and narrower at the bottom( the side where the edge of the knife is) because the human hand and fingers are built that way. I also belly the bottom of the handle so that the fingers conform, and the big knuckles line up in a row on the knife, while I use a lesser swell on the top side of the handle to fill the palm of the hand, and provide something for the web of the hand to grip. Some folks put a thumb groove on that one side of the grip, but I have not found that particularly useful, nor necessary for a good grip when a knife is under heavy use.
 
There's a guy that lives out in Kiowa that has a knife that looks just like the one you made. His knife has a guard that's shaped in a S fashion that doubles as a beer bottle opener. He's a very popular guy at rondez's.

Regards
Loyd Shindelbower
Loveland Colorado
 
Back
Top