The TVM fusil, while well-made and serviceable, is (as they are up-front about) a generic fusil rather than an exact copy of the known Tulle fusils de chasse. I have handled the TVM, a Centermark, a Narragansett, a Tip Curtis, and several Caywood trade guns of the French types, but to be honest I cannot tell you which is "better" on al counts that you list. The TVM is probably the least "authentic", but probably would rate highly in your other standards. I am having a Narragansett Armes one built now (delivery soon I hope). It is my understanding that Tip Curtis usually has several on hand and If I had known that, I might have ordered one from him.