I used a paste, but I haven't found what box its in from my last move, so I can't tell you which brand it is. I think I got it from Brownell's. I liked the idea that I could put a glop of it on a cleaning patch and cover a large area of the barrel with one swipe. I keep the propane torch on the section of barrel I am blueing, and when I have the whole barrel done, I remove the heat to spray the barrel with WD40 to cool it down. The oil burns at first, and I keep spraying it on until it stops sizzling, and stays wet looking. I most the spray can back and forth( up and down, as I actually suspend the barrel from a wire coat hanger from the track for my garage door ) The first time I tried this, I was not sure I had the whole barrel hot enough. so I used the torch to heat the barrel up again- burning off all the oil in the process. Then I cooled the barrel " Up " by spraying the muzzle and working my way up to the breech end that closest to the hook through the tang screw hole. I left newspapers on the floor to catch the dripping oil. I let it dry over night, and the next day, I first wiped off all the oil, then washed the barrel with cold water to remove any of the paste residue, then dried it, and degreased it with alcohol. At that stage it was back on the wire hook, and ready to redo. I prepared my cold blue on my cleaning patch, held by pliers, and then lit my propane torch and started to heat the barrel again. Each time I redid the blue, oil, and heating, the finish got darker, and seemed to go deeper. Each morning I check the barrel in good daylight, examining the barrel carefully for any patches, or lighter spots. Frankly after the second application, it was as dark as it would get. I did a third coat for piece of mind, and in deferrence to " Murphy's Law ".
I used the same technique with cold browning solution, ( Plum Brown ) to achieve a deep, dark, chocolate brown color on my shotgun. It has proven very durable, over the years.