• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Should I or should I not?

the hawken shop
L & R
Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Flintlock Whiskey

Flintlock Whiskey

54 Cal.
MLF Supporter
Joined
Aug 5, 2021
Messages
1,525
Reaction score
1,882
Location
Cave Creek Arizona
I acquired a Colt 1860 Army today. Now when I say Colt, I mean a reproduction gun made by Uberti for Colt that is a faithful reproduction. No proof marks or advisories stamped all over it. Never fired, matching serials, still in original wrapping and original oil that has become goo. As an aside, I didn't know the originals had steel back straps until today.
Anyway, I am torn between making it a safe queen or actually shooting it. Seriously I don't know what to do. If I shoot it I figure it will loose a hundred or so dollars in value.
Seriously, what would you do and why?
 
@Flintlock Whiskey this was discussed recently in the General forum under Do you actually use your expensive guns ...? Consensus of opinion was yes and no 😄 with more on the yes side. My opinion is that there isn't a right or a wrong answer. Personally, I have one pair of caplock derringers, in a beautiful boxed set, with all accoutrements, that I can't yet bring myself to shoot as they remain unfired since made in the 1980's. Maybe someday, but not today. The bell can't be unrung. While they aren't original Deringer pistols, thus far I appreciate them as examples of the gun makers art. I know this probably won't help you, but don't rush your decision.
 
The Miner '49er said:
@Flintlock Whiskey this was discussed recently in the General forum under Do you actually use your expensive guns ...? Consensus of opinion was yes and no 😄 with more on the yes side. My opinion is that there isn't a right or a wrong answer. Personally, I have one pair of caplock derringers, in a beautiful boxed set, with all accoutrements, that I can't yet bring myself to shoot as they remain unfired since made in the 1980's. Maybe someday, but not today. The bell can't be unrung. While they aren't original Deringer pistols, thus far I appreciate them as examples of the gun makers art. I know this probably won't help you, but don't rush your decision.
Click to expand...
Actually, your saying to don't rush it resonates with me, thanks.
 
If you have other guns to shoot, shoot them while you decide what to do. Your decision. Personally, I would not purchase a gun that I wouldn't shoot. How much pleasure will it give you sitting in the safe?
 
Consider if it were an unmentionable, like a popular gun that rhymes with "clock", my guess is everyone, myself too, would shoot it without a second thought. Why?, bc it could easily be replaced for an amount most could afford. Something like what the op has I don't believe is in that easily found and easily replaced category so IMHO that needs to be factored in this decision. No right, no wrong. This is a great example that those of us who merely have things like this to worry about are extremely lucky. Put it on display where you can see it and handle it whenever you want. That might give you great satisfaction. If not, load 'er up and press the trigger.
 
Flintlock Whiskey said:
Very good point, thanks.
Click to expand...
I was also in the same boat. It's a long story but I recieved a LeMatt revolver as a gift from a family friend that was unfired. I haven't shot it yet but I do plan on it. Yes it would be worth more u fired, but I'm never gonna sell it so I know I'll get more enjoyment out of it by firing it than just looking at it every now and again insode my safe. Just my 2 cents.
 
Since it's a repo shoot it and enjoy it. Hopefully a couple hundred dollars in value won't make or break you when reselling so let the next owner worry about any wear you put on it having fun. If it was a second generation Colt I'd be reluctant $$ wise. I have a 2nd gen Colt 1862 Police I haven't shot.....yet ;) YMMV
 
I would not presume to “tell you” what to do. I can only share my philosophy on the subject. EVERY firearm I purchase, modern or otherwise, I purchase with intent to use. My mantra has always been “All my guns are shooters”. Now I will grant that I have some firearms that remain unfired but that is because I simply haven’t gotten to range with that particular firearm (yet).
Life is far too short and uncertain to worry about the value of a material object “losing $100 in value”. If I spend hard earned $ to purchase something, you can bet I intend to enjoy it.
I know some may consider it heresy but I have a 2nd Generation Colt
2nd model Dragoon that I have fired and carried on horseback while riding with a living history cavalry unit. f615638a1631b912.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I have the same dilemma. I have three 2nd Gen Colts, all unfired, and they are so darn pretty I’m reluctant to shoot them.

FWIW, I believe the blackstrap is plated brass.
 
Last edited:
Flintlock Whiskey said:
I acquired a Colt 1860 Army today. Now when I say Colt, I mean a reproduction gun made by Uberti for Colt that is a faithful reproduction. No proof marks or advisories stamped all over it. Never fired, matching serials, still in original wrapping and original oil that has become goo. As an aside, I didn't know the originals had steel back straps until today.
Anyway, I am torn between making it a safe queen or actually shooting it. Seriously I don't know what to do. If I shoot it I figure it will loose a hundred or so dollars in value.
Seriously, what would you do and why?
Click to expand...
Did you buy a gun? Shoot the darn thing. If you bought it as an investment, stick it under your mattress or whatever, but a gun is meant to be used. I won’t buy a gun I won’t fire. “It will lose a hundred dollars or so in value.” For me, I don’t care one bit. The resale value of my guns is my kids’ lookout, not mine!
Jay
 
Flintlock Whiskey said:
I acquired a Colt 1860 Army today. Now when I say Colt, I mean a reproduction gun made by Uberti for Colt that is a faithful reproduction. No proof marks or advisories stamped all over it. Never fired, matching serials, still in original wrapping and original oil that has become goo. As an aside, I didn't know the originals had steel back straps until today.
Anyway, I am torn between making it a safe queen or actually shooting it. Seriously I don't know what to do. If I shoot it I figure it will loose a hundred or so dollars in value.
Seriously, what would you do and why?
Click to expand...
We all get tied up in that conundrum. If you "queen" it, it will remain un-touched by you and you may make some profit down the road, or you can shoot it and simply enjoy! BTW, I think the guy behind the current Henry Rifle company was the force behind the Colt Blackpowder Series; parts made in Italy, and finished and assembled here. They are a very popular collectible unto themselves. Good luck!
 

Similar threads

Jappo
Stoeger and Cimarron Walker
Replies
11
Views
503
Jappo
Jappo
TheDividQ
Help with Hawken Identification.
2
Replies
26
Views
1K
TheDividQ
TheDividQ
RiverRat
New Revolver To The Stable
Replies
8
Views
1K
Flintlock Whiskey
Flintlock Whiskey
Dave Markowitz
Ruggle Patent Underhammer by Rod Olsen
Replies
18
Views
1K
Sam squanch
Sam squanch
kh54
1855 Sidehammer Root original & reproduction
Replies
8
Views
1K
oldschoolhunter55
O

Latest posts

Back
Top