What caliber and style for you?

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Caliber is so much a function of intended use. For me, the .54 is perfect medicine for our larger northern whitetails. All my deer rifles are .54.

In flinters, I am drawn to the "Early Virginia" style, or "Colonial" as those are many times referred to. For comfort, I like the wider, flat buttplates.

2024-10-23_10-53-28.jpg


That said, the Isaac Haines (Lancaster) I have, which is to replicate RCA #81, is lighter weight, a beauty to look at, and shoots very well. Dave Person did a fantastic job of recreating #81 for me.

Original:

2024-11-23_04-36-19.jpg

2024-11-23_04-36-07.jpg


Recreation:

2024-11-23_04-33-31.jpg

2024-11-23_04-44-50.jpg

2024-11-23_04-34-34.jpg

2024-11-23_04-34-55.jpg

2024-11-23_04-36-59.jpg
 
Guess I'm the odd man out. If I were to have one built, it would be an Ohio Vincent full stock .36 caliber flintlock. Of course that is because it is what I learned to shoot a flintlock with my grandfather's original and a .36 is the only caliber I don't currently have ( with the exception of pistols) and I don't hunt any longer with the exception of a squirrel or two from my deck.
 
Incredible figuring of butt stock wood in first pic.
I believe Mike Brooks said that stock wood came out of a root. He said it was very hard wood. I had never seen figure quite like that before and could find no matching examples on the web.

2024-11-23_07-15-49.jpg
 
Caliber is so much a function of intended use. For me, the .54 is perfect medicine for our larger northern whitetails. All my deer rifles are .54.

In flinters, I am drawn to the "Early Virginia" style, or "Colonial" as those are many times referred to. For comfort, I like the wider, flat buttplates.

View attachment 363868

That said, the Isaac Haines (Lancaster) I have, which is to replicate RCA #81, is lighter weight, a beauty to look at, and shoots very well. Dave Person did a fantastic job of recreating #81 for me.

Original:

View attachment 363869
View attachment 363870

Recreation:

View attachment 363873
View attachment 363875
View attachment 363872
View attachment 363871
View attachment 363874
You are a lucky and well-funded man! 🫡
 
Last edited:
Back
Top