Caliber is so much a function of intended use. For me, the .54 is perfect medicine for our larger northern whitetails. All my deer rifles are .54.
In flinters, I am drawn to the "Early Virginia" style, or "Colonial" as those are many times referred to. For comfort, I like the wider, flat buttplates.
View attachment 363868
That said, the Isaac Haines (Lancaster) I have, which is to replicate RCA #81, is lighter weight, a beauty to look at, and shoots very well. Dave Person did a fantastic job of recreating #81 for me.
Original:
View attachment 363869
View attachment 363870
Recreation:
View attachment 363873
View attachment 363875
View attachment 363872
View attachment 363871
View attachment 363874