Opinions Requested on Next Kibler SMR Caliber

shop deals on amazon
Shop deals on ebay
Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Status
Not open for further replies.
wiscoaster

wiscoaster

75 Cal.
MLF Supporter
Joined
May 24, 2023
Messages
5,446
Reaction score
8,303
Location
Wis
I have a Kibler SMR .45 cal with walnut stock. Barrel and iron hardware are Jax-blacked. Thinking about ordering another SMR as a winter project. Probably maple-stocked for a change, and browned barrel and hardware. Undecided whether to get another .45 cal or to go with .36 cal for something different. I do like .45 cal and mine shoots great. Goals are mainly just the project with an end result of just target shooting and not hunting. Opinions on whether to go .36 cal or .45 cal?
 
I have the Kibler SMR in .36. Very sweet shooting and miserly on lead and powder. Besides being fun to shoot, it's deadly on small game. I really like mine, except I wish it had more drop at the comb.

That said, a .40 lets you use a 3/8" ramrod, is still miserly on lead and powder, and will give better wind resistance. I bought one of Roundball's .40's when he was reducing his herd and it was really a fun and accurate rifle to shoot. I sold it because I couldn't use it for small game in MN during an open big game season lest I was also carrying a valid deer tag as the assumption here is if you're carrying a deer legal gun, you ARE hunting deer. For targets though, a very good choice, even though that wasn't a choice you asked about. 🙂

Lastly...why do you want two guns that are only different in wood selection? I'd take the opportunity to change up the caliber as well.
 
A woodsrunner in a small caliber would be excellent, at least for me. The really long SMR barrel in a small caliber just seems like it would be very front heavy. I like a rifle to balance more to the rear.
 
Spikebuck said:
.....🙂

Lastly...why do you want two guns that are only different in wood selection? I'd take the opportunity to change up the caliber as well.
Click to expand...
Exactly why I'm asking. Thank you. Maybe I should also consider .40 cal. That would be a little lighter in weight than a .36 cal, no? Main reason for .36 cal as the alternate SMR caliber choice is I already have a couple hand guns in .36 cal and so wouldn't have to stock yet another different round ball size.

Reason for different wood selection is just, well, to be different. ;)
 
Last edited:
As for me, I like different kinds of wood more than different calibers. I have three Kibler SMRs stocked in pear, ash and oak. I think they are 45, 36 and 40. I put them back in their boxes, waiting time to assemble them, so I'm not sure about the calibers. In practical terms, to keep things simple, sticking with a single caliber makes the most sense. Another 45 would be a good choice.
 
Last edited:
wiscoaster said:
Goals are mainly just the project with an end result of just target shooting and not hunting. Opinions on whether to go .36 cal or .45 cal?
Click to expand...
Type of targeting shooting and distance may come into play. Currently I am ‘out of stock’ in 36 and 40 caliber long guns, but enjoy shooting a couple in 32 caliber. Fantastic at 25 yards, ok at 50 and quite the challenge at 100 yards, particularly in any kind of crosswind. A 36 caliber would definitely reach out a bit further, depends what you are shooting at. Easy enough to hit steel with smaller calibers, though a hit doesn’t mean the steel is going to fall.

You say you have a 45 caliber that shoots great. Maybe that’s a 40 you hear calling instead of a 36 or another 45? Really can’t go wrong in any available caliber if you want it in my opinion.

What caliber do you really think you want?
 
wiscoaster said:
...Main reason for .36 cal as the alternate SMR caliber choice is I already have a couple hand guns in .36 cal and so wouldn't have to stock yet another different round ball size.
Click to expand...
Hard to argue with that as it's what I've done myself. All of my deer rifles are now .54. I eliminated the .32, .40, .45, .50, .58, and .62. I do still have a .62 smooth rifle, but that's for turkey or small game with shot. The .36 is for small game. So went from stocking for 8 calibers of rifles to two plus shot components for 1. 👍
 
That was my sole reason for choosing a .32. Already had the stuff for it so saved money on having to pick up the stuff for another caliber for now at least.
 
For those of you who have a Kibler SMR in .32 would it be possible to show us the balance point on the rifle?

Yes, I know it will be slightly different due to wood and wood density but close enough for me to make a decision.
 
My last few purchases including a Kibler Woods Runner have been in .54 caliber. I try to keep them all same size now, helping with ball size and rod tool inventory. It just helps me to not show up at the range with the wrong ball and equipment for the rifle I am using. Just my point of view. Enjoy your winter build, whatever your choice.
 
French Colonial said:
For those of you who have a Kibler SMR in .32 would it be possible to show us the balance point on the rifle?

Yes, I know it will be slightly different due to wood and wood density but close enough for me to make a decision.
Click to expand...
IMG_20241123_140934119_HDR.jpg

Walnut stock.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

R
Thoughts on Kibler Woodsrunner vs Southern Mountain rifle.
2
Replies
26
Views
1K
Rock Home Isle
Rock Home Isle
BaldEagleFL
Building my first Kibler.
Replies
9
Views
615
Buff1958
Buff1958
WarDawg
Pondering a flintlock. Educate me.
2 3
Replies
45
Views
3K
CyrusP
CyrusP
Chmachin
  • Locked
WITHDRAWN Kibler SMR .45 Cal.
Replies
6
Views
769
Chmachin
Chmachin
J
T/C Patriot in presentation case
Replies
2
Views
234
Newly O’Brian
Newly O’Brian

Latest posts

Back
Top