- Joined
- Nov 1, 2018
- Messages
- 3,838
- Reaction score
- 2,867
I'm not sure if there ever was a Brown Bess carbine, historically, but the carbine I have is very comfortable to shoot. However, I think the pedersoli carbine, like I have, would be better with about three-four more inches of barrel, as it is very slightly butt-heavy when you carry it one handed. But, I find it very balanced for aiming. For some reason, I've never been bothered by recoil, but I've heard others complain about it with the carbine. My carbine likes loads on the heavy side also, for best accuracy, but unless I'm shooting with only a t-shirt on, the recoil, and killer-buttplate does not bother me. The heel and comb also seem to fit me well. I do know however, that when the comb does not fit one's face and/or physique, that's a painful proposition. !!!!
The Pedersoli Brown Bess muskets are loosely based on a commercial short land Bess; these muskets were designed to be less comfortable to shoot and easier to shoulder. The Brown Bess typically has a lot of wood in butt, comb, wrist and forestoc making it unbalanced.... the best Brown Bess I’ve shot was 1742 long land; the butt drops slightly more at the heal and forestock is thick to balance the overall weight. A 1740 shortland Brown Bess would be an ideal huntiging musket; I’ve seen a few at the revolutionary war museum in Yorktown.