• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

A well made tomahawk ?

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Status
Not open for further replies.

bigbore442001

50 Cal.
Joined
Nov 25, 2004
Messages
1,167
Reaction score
6
Location
New England
I bought a book the other day, The Fighting Tomahawk by McLemore. What a fascinating book on how to effectively use the tomahawk in self defense as well as some historical knowlegde on it as well.

I would like some opinions on a well made tomahawk that is available? I know there are many manufacturers but I would like to know who makes one of the better ones out there. Thank you for any replies.
 
I like the ones from Smiling Fox Forge and H&B. Joe DeLaRonde makes some durn nice customs!
 
Bigbore,
You can't go wrong and you will not be sorry if you invest in an H&B Forge tomahawk.
Mark
 
The first thing you want to learn from such books is that its Called, " HAND-TO HAND " fighting, and that means you are mostly likely to get hurt, Too! Its nice to know how to use these ancient arms to defend yourself, but it takes years of training to become proficient, and there are a lot better tools to use for self defense than a knife or hawk.

The age of multiple capacity magazine guns came about the same time that physical assaults became multiple ASSAILANTS rather than involving only one person. That hand held weapon is useless against more than one attacker, or if any of your enemies is armed with a gun.

By all means, take martial arts training. It will not only teach you basics that are used in all the martial arts, but it will teach you how to observe, what to see, and HOW TO THINK! Those are the critical skills you need to survive any attack, especially when you are facing greater numbers of attackers. Practice, always with plastic, or wooden "tools" they can be sticks, and don't even have to be shaped like a hawk. That will come later.

A lot of modern hawks use for combat come made out of a single piece of steel, for strength. Everyone likes the idea of a war hawk, with a 2 inch wide blade, and a spike or dagger off the back end of the head, hanging from a 20 inch or longer handle. It looked good in " Last of the Mohigans" didn't it?? It looked pretty darn good in Mel Gibson's " The Patriot", too. But read the books like Mclemore's. You will get past the Hollywood choreography, and find out about real fighting with a hawk.

You don't learn how to fire a gun from a Hollywood production, and I certainly hope you don't take seriously any movie idea on how to use a hawk to fight.
 
You don't learn how to fire a gun from a Hollywood production, and I certainly hope you don't take seriously any movie idea on how to use a hawk to fight.

Amen brother!
 
Beaver Bill makes a great tomahawk. He's out of Oxford Ohio.
 
I have that book, and enjoyed reading it.

He employs a lot of Samurai techniques.

Being a student of sword for over 30 years. I can say hand to hand weapons do have thier place in the modern battlefield. You best be able to pick your fight.

As a last ditch defensive stand. I would use my sword first, then my hawk and knife last.

I have had a 1750s Heron hawk for years. I resently bought a modern SOG hawk. Im going to sell it to a friend at work.

I would not buy any hawk thats advertised as a "throwing hawk"

For Id never throw mine away
 
bigbore442001 said:
I would like some opinions on a well made tomahawk that is available?

This seems to get asked every couple of months. Please define "well made tomahawk"? Are you talking about the content of the metal? The quality of the engraving?

Being made of metal and having no moving parts, a tomahawk will last a lifetime. A $20 hawk will do everything a $300 hawk will do, it just won't look as pretty doing it.

What do you want it to do? Are you looking to throw it or hang it on the wall?
 
Beaver Bill made the Spike Hawk and it is an awesome weapon. :shocked2:

Finished%20hawk.JPG
 
NWTF Longhunter said:
Beaver Bill made the Spike Hawk and it is an awesome weapon. :shocked2:

Finished%20hawk.JPG

You always have some nice equipment to share. :thumbsup:
 
is there a place I can buy the curly maple handles, I've got a hawk that looks allot like that I've had for years, would love a curly maple handle for it. Thanks
Chris
 
Given the choice in a fight, i would use a large, well made bowie before I went to the typical small hawk. IMO, the typical old style tomahawk is like a small belt axe. Too small to really do the job it was intended to do. Notice that most European style hand axes, be they a combat weapon or hatchet, are considerably larger than a tomahawk. Some very experienced smiths are now saying that the typical 10 x 2 inch drop point "cutting competition" knife will outperform pretty much any modern belt axe, plus do all of the things that a knife will do. When was the last time you saw a tomahawk that could chop though a 2 x 4 in 2.5 seconds? :wink:
 
Joe Mandt said:
Some very experienced smiths are now saying that the typical 10 x 2 inch drop point "cutting competition" knife will outperform pretty much any modern belt axe, plus do all of the things that a knife will do. When was the last time you saw a tomahawk that could chop though a 2 x 4 in 2.5 seconds? :wink:

Yes, we know that you make large Bowies and will start promoting them, but a hawk will sever the spinal cord at the back of the neck, or penetrate the skull. Chopping through a 2x4 is not a prerequisite for the weapon.
 
But a typical meat cleaver would do it better. :wink: What I am "selling" is hardly relevant. (I actually joined this forum to pick up pointwers on how to build muzzleloaders) People on here are likely to buy a hawk as it was carried back in the 18th and 19th Centuries. I was just commenting that it is not the ideal weapon or field tool when compared to other edged weapons of the same period. I would say the same thing about the Sheffield made mid-sized "bowie hunters" that were sold in droves during the post Civil War era.
 
but a hawk will sever the spinal cord at the back of the neck, or penetrate the skull.
and so will I properly made big knife - be glad to demonstrate it - any volunteers???

And Carl you're constant innuendo about makers being here for no other reason than to "push" their goods gets a bit tiring - we like to have fun and show off too - it is NOT business 24/7/365, in fact I come here mostly to get away from business and suspect it is the same for others ike Mike Brooks, Wick Ellerbe, et al - so why not give it a rest? or if it really sticks in your craw so much maybe you should report us to Claude or one of the mods - whose job it rightfully is to make those decisions.....it's been a veeeery long day today....

BTW - welcome aboard Joe! :thumbsup:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top