Another Pig Sticker

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Loving that blade shape, the wood you used for the handles are really nice, but there's one problem, it's in unused perfect condition!!

That nice blade shape needs to be worn down a bit from sharpening, and the handle needs to be blood and sweat stained. :grin:
 
Brasilikilt said:
Loving that blade shape, the wood you used for the handles are really nice, but there's one problem, it's in unused perfect condition!!

That nice blade shape needs to be worn down a bit from sharpening, and the handle needs to be blood and sweat stained. :grin:
In time, In time!
Even the recovered originals were new at one time! :wink:
 
Starrett does the forging, I do the shaping. :wink:
At one time I was tinkering with the idea of learning to forge my own, but decided against it due to the fact that to get the most from a piece of steel that it is capable of, one really needs to be a master smith.(and that takes years)
Not knocking the boys that forge their own, Hats off to them.
I use mostly A-2 and in my mind a steel that is forged by the manufacture under strict quality control guide lines then Heat treated in a evenflo oven at precise temps, I know exactly what I am dealing with. No guessing or judging of colors, I know the blade is everything that it has the potential to be.
The few knifes I sell I warranty for life and do not want any coming back, So you can see why I want the most a steel has to offer.
I never have or will claim to offer completely PC/HC knives do to the use of modern steel, only in styles of knives do i claim any PC/HC reference.
Again not knocking anyone who forges blades, More power to them.
OK fellas I'm sure I ruffled some feathers, Let the thrashings begin :v
 
No thrashing here. The knife you sent Wes is the best balanced knife I have held in a long time. The guys I have showed it to also agree with me. A person would be hard pressed to find a better knife!!
 
Just to add a bit to what James said. Forging todays steel does absolutely nothing, zip, zero, zilch, nada, to improve it. Forging is simply one of three basic ways to form steel today. In the end, with cast steel as an exception, but not as much an exception as many might think, it is the heat treat that determines the performance of the steel for a particular use. Only in cases of radical bends in a product, does forging help by being able to turn the object in a curve and have the grain follow suit. As in a crankshaft. Even then it is not as important as once thought, but will give a small percentage of added strength. In a knife blade, it is of no consequence as to following shape, unless the shape is very radical. Grain in steel is much like flake board, except it runs in one direction, which cannot be changed within the bar, as it is directionally set when the steel is rolled at the mill. but is still like flakeboard. Steel grain is shaped similar to an egg. It is only oblong by a little bit. The size and number of the grains can be changed, but only by heat for the most part. To a large degree, the smaller the grain, the stronger the steel, but again, only heat can do that without the steel being stressed and weakened, as in hammering when the steel is too cold. Doing so does also make smaller grains, but makes the grain boundaries larger, thus making the matrix weaker. To sum it up, judging the quailty of any product of steel, depends much more on the proper heat treatment of the steel than how it was shaped.
 
Lonehunter, I dont think any body can really say you are doing something wrong by the way you make your knives if you can shape it and heat treat it well your good to go. Yeah your method isn't 100% PC /HC but does it really matter maybe if your a purist or pc freak you want to have your hardware and clothing as close to what a original would be made and look like fine. You have nothing to be concerned about your knives look great,and if you have all the high end gear to make your knives then good for you, others don't and even those that hand forge beginning to end do stock removal to some degree. My buddy that allows me to use his forge thinks grinding a knife out is to impersonal I think differently I like the idea of doing it both ways if you want to make a pattern welded blade you can forge weld your own up out of what ever you got and then shape it or you have to buy bar stock already made up from someone wich cost a good bit and then grind to profile your blade So you got choices you just gotta do what ever.
 
If your referring to me ! dont know if I would be classified as a great mind maybe a Einstein!! :rotf:
 
Back
Top