I prefer rust brown on the barrel even though the process is slow. Somehow, in my brain, a flintlock rifle barrel should be a deep brown, smooth like the underside of a Hershey bar.
A builder taught me how. Preparing a browning box and using a proper wet heat procedure ensures such a finish, he said, and following his advice, and being patient, I have found he was right. I used to brown the barrels of production guns just to get that look. Actually, that is the only thing I did to my Colonial that didn't require me to refer to Jim's videos in assembly. I am not so good at the other tasks unless I am very, very careful. It took me 2 months to have a completed rifle.
I do not have the confidence to do the lock. Yet. So I left it in the white as per one of Jim's suggestions. I'm still in surgery rehab so don't have a photograph, unless I have one on the phone. I shall look. Oh, BTW, the quality wooden shipping box of Kibler kits make for an adequate browning box.
.