I recently picked one up in 58 caliber. While a 1" barrel is standard for 58 cals these days, this one has a 15/16" x 28" barrel, making it as much as a pound lighter than the Lyman GPR in 54 cal with its 32" barrel. Balance of the 58 is very slightly muzzleheavy, useful for offhand shooting, even if it swings better than the GPR.
Workmanship is excellent, and at a glance it looks more like a Lyman Trade Rifle, but with a little lower comb. Mine is accurate as a snakebite, and it may quickly become my do-all deer rifle even with 5 other 58's in the rack.
The only thing I didn't particularly like was the trigger, either when set or not. As a test I pulled the
R.E. Davis Deerslayer from one of my GPR's and tried that for size. It's hand-in-glove, just like on the GPR, even thouhgh Davis intended it for the TC Hawken. Go figger, but it's the best $41 I have spent on many a rifle.
Only small hitch, even though it dropped right into the mortise and worked perfectly before I put the trigger guard back on, seating the trigger guard screws pushed the trigger too deep in the front of the mortise and interfered with function. That was an easy fix once I diagnosed the issue. I just ran a small brass flathead woodscrew into the bottom of the mortise and adjusted its height to give a secure stop to for the trigger plate when the trigger guard is tightened down. Took a good 2 minutes ones I figgered out the problem. Now it has a very clean pull of about 4 pounds with the trigger unset, and a very clean 8 ounces or so when set. Best of all for my addled brain, the rear set trigger is a completely different shape that the front trigger so I have no tendency to confuse them in the heat of the moment.
Sorry for the long roll, but I'm obviously happy. If I find another in 45 at the right price I might pick it up simply because I don't own any 45's at the moment. If my experience is any indicator, you have a real proud shooter on your hands.