Whoa!! I knew you guys were my people when I first started reading this forum. I will have to go back and read this whole thread soon.
Brewing was my first love and i left teaching high school to open a small farm brewery with a couple of partners in southern Illinois in 2013. I left the company to move west but they're still going strong. I implore any of you in that neighborhood to visit
Scratch Brewing. I think everyone here would truly enjoy the place. They've done quite well since I've been gone. Get yourself a bottle of their chanterelle biere de garde and wild cherry biere de garde.
I continued working in the brewing industry as a brewer and then quality manager up until a year ago when I needed to better financially support my family.
I am going to have to get that 18th century libations book. Looks interesting.
Here are some suggestions for interesting beers to brew:
Scottish hickory bark ale:
Find a Scottish 80 schilling recipe. Low bitterness, very malty and cooper to ruby brown, with caramel and fig flavors from malt. Find a shagbark hickory tree and remove some bark. Toast that bark in the oven at 400-450F ish for an hour ish or until the bark becomes really aromatic and changes color. If it starts to smoke pull it out. Put the bark into the boil for about an hour. You need a good amount of bark. I'd estimate that the bark in the pot should be about 25% of the volume of wort. This beer will have a slight toasted marshmallow quality from the bark.
Sassafras leave (or file') pale
Safale s04 English yeast is good
Pale ale malt base to about 6%
Marris otter 80%
British crystal 15-20L 10%
British crystal 60L 5%
Golden toasted oat malt 5%
Mash at 154F
Bittering hop addition to 15ibu
East Kent Golding hops at 5 min to end of boil probably about 0.5-1 oz per 5 gal batch
Find a sassafras tree and pull a ton of leaves, preferably left on branches. Hang to dry. Strip leaves off the branches and put into a mesh bag in the boil for the last 10 minutes. I would estimate the amount needed to be about 20% of the boil volume in dry PACKED leaves. So if doing a 5 gal batch, have about a 1 gal jar packed somewhat tight with dried leaves ready that you'll use.
Cedar ipa (for those that like IPA)
7-8% abv
Safale s04 English yeast
Maris otter 68%
Flaked oats 10%
Munich malt 15%
American crystal 40L 7%
Mash at 154F
Chinook bittering hops to 25ibu
Simcoe and Chinook aroma hops at flameout about 1oz each for 5.5 gal batch
Find an eastern red cedar tree and pull about 1 - 2 pounds of blue cedar berries (actually juniper species. True cedar is toxic). You may want to start on low end for amount of berries but I think 1.5 lb is safe for 5.5 gal end yield batch. Put berries in food processor to bust up but don't go super fine. It's ok to have some of the green branch leaf material in it. Put in mesh bag in boil 5 min before flameout.
Dryhop near end of fermentation with 1oz Simcoe and 1 oz Chinook.
These are off of memory so the exact amounts may be a little off. I believe all these recipes are in the Homebrewers Almanac book. I get no royalties on it
it's a good book though
Also, I'd you want to use some wild hops, travel along old railroad tracks or former rail lines in August. You may find old hops vines that have grown from hops that fell off of rail cars back in the 1800s. Or, they could be native, but likely not. Pick them late summer when they start to feel dry and the lupulin is bright yellow (not school bus yellow as they might be too old at that point). Give them a squeeze and if they smell good, use them. If they smell onion like or rancid or like parmesan, don't use them. Either use them right away or dry them in a food dehydrator on lowest heat until they stop losing moisture and then either vacuum pack and freeze them for a short bit or use them immediately.