• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

First flintlock deer

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Winchester97

40 Cal
Joined
Oct 24, 2020
Messages
395
Reaction score
580
I finally connected on a nice fat doe with my .40 cal flintlock. I developed a load using 70gr 3f black powder, a durofelt wad lubed with deer tallow/ beeswax/ olive oil, and a 175gr .401 bullet from an Accurate mold. I was able to get 1.5" groups at 50yd, and 3" at 100yd with this combo. Pictured below is the bullet, along with the recovered bullet.
20230108_195713.jpg

I had one doe tag left in my county as Ohio's muzzleloader season opened on Saturday. I elected to hunt from an elevated blind overlooking a small foodplot with 60yd max shot distance.
20230107_081511.jpg
I got all situated about 40 minutes before legal time, and discovered a 4ft long rifle doesn't fit well in a 5ft box blind. About 20 min later I watched a very nice buck walk out in the moonlight, mill around, and leave after about 10 minutes. Next was a small buck about 8 am. He walked past at 50yd and headed off to bed. Both were safe as I needed a doe.
I had my wife hunt that evening, as she still had a buck tag, thinking that nice buck I saw might show up during legal time for her. Her evening ended with 5 big does at 25-50 yd. Feeding in the foodplot, she let them go, waiting on her buck.
Sunday morning I skipped church and hunted again, catching a glimpse of 2 does in heavy brush, but no chance for a shot.
That evening found me sitting in the blind again overlooking the plot. I got in at 3pm, and was enjoying the crisp weather, when the neighbors comenced to firing about 500rd of .556 and pistol rounds in their woods 200yd away. I just drank my coffee, and hoped they would hang it up soon.
The shooting stopped at about 4:30, and at 4:45 I heard a stick pop to my right the old apple orchard. I caught sight of a doe picking through the brush heading for a lane I had trimmed. I slowly got to my knees in the blind, manuvered the rifle out the window and waited. After a few minutes she entered the opening, I stopped her with a grunt and focused on the sights, placing them right behind her shoulder. The flash and recoil seemed instantanious, and she spun around running the path she came from for 10yd, then turned hard to the right away from me and ran straight up a steep hill 30yd before I heard her crash.
After recovering her, I found the bullet hit a bit forward and had passed through both shoulders,lungs, and was caught in the offside hide. She had her right leg back, and left stretched forward at the shot, otherwise I would have gotten a passthrough. That bullet did it's job, and I was more excited about this doe than the last few bucks I killed. I'm most definantly hooked.
20230108_172526.jpg
 
Last edited:
A nice story to read thanks for sharing.I would of thought that the long barrel would be for a round ball but it is that accurate with the conical huh
Really surpised me as well. I just didn't feel comfortable shooting a deer with that little roundball, so started testing different bullets. It's a 1-48 deep groove green mountain barrel that's super accurate with roundball, but after trying several bullets over the summer, this one proved to be plenty accurate. I assume the powder charge is high enough that it's stabilizing the bullet, as I had little accuracy until I got above 50gr. During testing.
 
Congrats on a fantastic hunt and harvest! Developing the right load and bullet combo definitely pays itself off! She looks like a pretty health doe so, enjoy the rewards my friend! 👍
 
Congratulations! I enjoyed the story also. I wanted to try shooting one of those bullets in my forty but haven't tried it yet.
Thanks, I tried about 4 styles with poor results, after I tried this one with a wad and sized to just fit the bore at .401 with medium resistance, I got some good results. Keep trying, I figured if a 1-48 .45 hawken could shoot a conical well, why not a .40.
 
congrats on your kill, have been trying different conicals in my .40 without much luck. But this gives me hope :thumb:
Just keep trying til you find the right combo, probably will not match the accuracy of a ball and patch, but might come close.
 
Really surpised me as well. I just didn't feel comfortable shooting a deer with that little roundball, so started testing different bullets. It's a 1-48 deep groove green mountain barrel that's super accurate with roundball, but after trying several bullets over the summer, this one proved to be plenty accurate. I assume the powder charge is high enough that it's stabilizing the bullet, as I had little accuracy until I got above 50gr. During testing.
OH YEAH 1/48 is compromising twist.I didnt know that it was 1/48...and i have one.
 
Congratulations! Great story and result! :thumb:

It certainly is possible to shoot conicals from slower twist barrels. I don't have a .40, but shot conicals from several of my .54 caliber 1-66 twist Pedersoli rifles with tremendous accuracy out to 125 yards. I didn't have any success with solid flat based bullets, but they loved Buffalo Ballets and Hornady Great Plains bullets, both of which had hollow bases. No wad needed in my case.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top