While there is no arguement that a well placed 50 grain charge, shot placement being correct is more then enough to take a deer under most circumstances. Sill, if you can get the same kind of, or near accuracy with a greater powder charge, wouldn't you be further ahead to use that?
What of longer range shots, where perhaps a great bullet speed would be a desired factor. What if with the proper shot placement you stood the chance of driving that projectile through the body creating perhaps a better blood trail or breaking them down so they drop in their track or near to it.
I will not argue that a light load putting a projectile in the correct place is all that is necessary to take deer. I will contend that if I can produce similar or near accuracy with a much greater charge, I will opt for the stronger charge each and every time.
What of longer range shots, where perhaps a great bullet speed would be a desired factor. What if with the proper shot placement you stood the chance of driving that projectile through the body creating perhaps a better blood trail or breaking them down so they drop in their track or near to it.
I will not argue that a light load putting a projectile in the correct place is all that is necessary to take deer. I will contend that if I can produce similar or near accuracy with a much greater charge, I will opt for the stronger charge each and every time.