Col. Batguano
75 Cal.
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2011
- Messages
- 5,039
- Reaction score
- 1,426
While the money the stock suppliers in maple stocks get for their product generally comes from the figure and the curl, the more important aspects are grain direction at the wrist and hardness of the wood. Our wrists are (or at least should be) exceedingly thin. Very long guns can focus a lot of leveraged force on that wrist if you drop the gun, or something on it in the middle. Furthermore, in inletting our lock and trigger internals we remove a lot of wood in that critical area weakening it further. Grain direction is critical to lend strength. Of course, if it's wrong and has a out of runout at the wrist it can be reinforced with a plug under the TG, or a rod in to the butt.
In order to get that natural "turn" in the grain the wood has to be harvested from a place it naturally does that. That's right at the base of the tree, and from the below-ground stump. It's far far easier to cut down a tree above ground than it is below ground!
The other aspect that goes to strength is wood hardness which also corresponds to sheer strength. Sugar maple is about 25%-30% harder (generically speaking) than red maple. Sheer strength closely corresponds to hardness in the individual blank. Harder wood also holds intricate details better in carving.
Wood with a lot of curl and figure in it is also inherently weaker than straight grained wood, and curled wood is going to seasonally move on you in 3 directions rather than two. * I have a gun where the front of the MC is flush to the muzzle face in August, and 1/16" below it in March!.
Sugar maple is also much less commonly curled than red maple. Daniel at Dunlops told me that roughly 1 blank in 500 has rich deep curl running throughout. Add in the grain direction turn and hardness requirements and now you're talking about 1/1000-2000 stocks. In fact, before he would sell me that $850 piece of wood, he wanted to see at least 2 examples of my past work. It was like going through an adoption process akin to buying a puppy! Since I was building a Lehigh styled gun with an A-weight barreled gun, the wrist was going to be very very thin. If I was building a D-Weighed barreled Lancaster, that grain turn aspect wouldn't be so critical in the stock. So given all of that, it's small wonder they ask the big big bucks for those super rare and perfect stocks.
A totally speculative guess in pricing is that if the demand for maple were the same as it is for walnut, that perfect maple blank would be priced 3x-5x higher. Want to help keep prices down? Keep the joy of ML'er building a secret!
In order to get that natural "turn" in the grain the wood has to be harvested from a place it naturally does that. That's right at the base of the tree, and from the below-ground stump. It's far far easier to cut down a tree above ground than it is below ground!
The other aspect that goes to strength is wood hardness which also corresponds to sheer strength. Sugar maple is about 25%-30% harder (generically speaking) than red maple. Sheer strength closely corresponds to hardness in the individual blank. Harder wood also holds intricate details better in carving.
Wood with a lot of curl and figure in it is also inherently weaker than straight grained wood, and curled wood is going to seasonally move on you in 3 directions rather than two. * I have a gun where the front of the MC is flush to the muzzle face in August, and 1/16" below it in March!.
Sugar maple is also much less commonly curled than red maple. Daniel at Dunlops told me that roughly 1 blank in 500 has rich deep curl running throughout. Add in the grain direction turn and hardness requirements and now you're talking about 1/1000-2000 stocks. In fact, before he would sell me that $850 piece of wood, he wanted to see at least 2 examples of my past work. It was like going through an adoption process akin to buying a puppy! Since I was building a Lehigh styled gun with an A-weight barreled gun, the wrist was going to be very very thin. If I was building a D-Weighed barreled Lancaster, that grain turn aspect wouldn't be so critical in the stock. So given all of that, it's small wonder they ask the big big bucks for those super rare and perfect stocks.
A totally speculative guess in pricing is that if the demand for maple were the same as it is for walnut, that perfect maple blank would be priced 3x-5x higher. Want to help keep prices down? Keep the joy of ML'er building a secret!
Last edited: