First thing to learn about muzzle loaders is any change can make a change!
Too me that was the first lesson I learned. For consistency you need to become regimented.
And never consider one thing has made a difference until you have fired at least a half of dozen rounds.
Also if you are looking to find out if a change made a difference shoot from the bench position. You want everything as absolutely steady and repeatable as it can possibly be to figure out where the problem is!
What I am trying to say is when you are changing powder increments you go up 5 grs. like the lady said. While you are trying that 5gr. increase you don't change anything else. You don't change lube, you don't change patch thickness, you don't change wiping practices, etc, etc. You keep all things except for the powder increase the same.
What you may not realize is that any one change can and usually makes a change on POI, (point of impact)!
When I first started shooting I started with a sub and I could not seem to get good consistency! I switched to real black and liked it's performance better. But I still was not pleased with my consistency. I tried experimenting with a 5 gr. increase in powder until I found something me and the rifle begin to agree on. Then I changed my lube and I liked it better.
Now days I know when I shoot what I want to shoot for a powder load, patch thickness and lube, I also have a wiping procedure I use I wipe every third shot when shooting at the range!
So I pretty much know if I ain't hitting consistently when at the range, it ain't the gun it's me. I either had too much coffee or not enough! :wink: