Doc: You can't get anywhere until you use calipers to actually measure the diameter of that barrel. My 20 gauge barrel turned out to be way oversized, at .626, rather than .620. I had to order 19 gauge wads in order to get any consistency with RB at any kind of distance.
If your gun is overbored, like mine, then order 18 gauge OP wads and OS cards. You can continue to use the 20 ga. cushion wads, since they are soft, and will collapse and spread out to seal the barrel between the PRB and the OP wad. You should not need the OS card until you are shooting shot loads.
I saw a 200+ increase in the velocity of my load when I switched from using the 20 gauge OP wads to the 19 gauge OP wads. Accuracy began to actually exist with the new wads.
Once you measure that bore, let us know, and we can give you our pet loading techniques while you are waiting for the new wads to come in. My brother and I have identical Fowlers, with the same barrel material used in each. Between the two of us, we have figured out how to get the best accuracy out of these fowlers, with the lowest SDV. No reason for you to have to repeat the exercise. Its getting close to deer season and I would like to see you have that gun in the field. Do check the bedding, and slot those underlugs so that the stock can expand and shrink with moisture conditions. That little trick has saved a lot of guns from being thrown in a scrap heap. You may want to go to a home store, or big hardware store to buy one of those drill bits that can cut sideways. That's the fastest way to slot the pin hole in the lug( NOT THE STOCK!)