I would like to have seen this particular project knife that failed, I've never run into that problem in my 19 years as a knifemaker but I never stop learning and there's always something a person has never seen before. I have no doubt that your proffesional knifemaker friend knew exactly what he was doing,All of the best of the best run into problems with a knife or two on occasion. I've found that if a piece of steel has a set that give me repeated trouble that I must bring that piece up over 1800 degree's for a time, which I do in forging anyway, that way the molecular memory is rearranged to your forgings, making It very important to forge evenly on both sides of the blade lest you creat uneven stresses when the blade is forged down below critical temps. If you do not, warpage is almost immenant when the blade is heat treated. Files can present their own set of problems if the teeth of the file are not ground away first before forging because if they are forged in to the blade, they can cause undo stress points along the edge and create micro cracks upon hardenig the edge, not always but it does happen often. I use mostly factory barstock these days,as it's very much easier to use since salvaged steel usually dosen't come in a very usable proportion, and doing this for a living means time is money,( I hate that aspect of the business), and it can be a real pain if every time you want to forge a knife you have to reproportion a piece of steel before you actually start forging the knife. The only exceptions I make these day's is for my ball bearing blades, as that type of steel(52100) is not readily available from a factory, and when it is offered the price is too much. Wes