I used Castor oil (CO) and denatured alcohol (DA) for a couple of years, as a Dutch Schultz style "dry" lubed patch, although I don't currently use it. It shot with accuracy. I just found that mink oil from Track of the Wolf gave me good accuracy too and I find it more convenient.
I will say up front that you don't want to lube patches too much ahead of time with CO/DA, it will break down the patch material within a couple months in my experience.
My rifle prefers a 6:1 ratio, 6 parts DA to 1 part CO. Dutch will tell you that most rifles like somewhere between a 5:1 and a 9:1 ratio, with 7:1 being the winner a majority of the time according to the folks that use his system and have reported back to him.
With Castor oil you have to use denatured alcohol to thin out the lube (get them to mix together), it won't mix with water like Ballistol. By making a solution you thin the amount of lube actually applied to the patch, and it makes for a way to apply the same amount of lube to every patch consistently. After mixing well and dipping patches, they are set on wax paper or a screen for a while so the DA can evaporate off and leave only the CO on the patch. They feel "dry" due to having a very minimal amount of lube on them.
I like to swab between shots, so I can't speak as to how well it will load without a cleaning patch.
I have read where some folks use the above as a wet patch type lube too. They take the solution of CO/DA out to the range with them, dip patches and squeeze the excess out, and then load right away. They are able to load without swabbing.
I will say up front that you don't want to lube patches too much ahead of time with CO/DA, it will break down the patch material within a couple months in my experience.
My rifle prefers a 6:1 ratio, 6 parts DA to 1 part CO. Dutch will tell you that most rifles like somewhere between a 5:1 and a 9:1 ratio, with 7:1 being the winner a majority of the time according to the folks that use his system and have reported back to him.
With Castor oil you have to use denatured alcohol to thin out the lube (get them to mix together), it won't mix with water like Ballistol. By making a solution you thin the amount of lube actually applied to the patch, and it makes for a way to apply the same amount of lube to every patch consistently. After mixing well and dipping patches, they are set on wax paper or a screen for a while so the DA can evaporate off and leave only the CO on the patch. They feel "dry" due to having a very minimal amount of lube on them.
I like to swab between shots, so I can't speak as to how well it will load without a cleaning patch.
I have read where some folks use the above as a wet patch type lube too. They take the solution of CO/DA out to the range with them, dip patches and squeeze the excess out, and then load right away. They are able to load without swabbing.