HI K, Is this a patchbox you made? or is it one out of one of the catalogues? My lids measure 1-1/2" wide, but I use a 5-1/4" butt plate. What size butt plate are you using? If its to narrow, it will throw off the proportions, 1" seems kind of narrow. My first gun, had a short butt plate 4-1/4" with a 1" lid and it looks a little out of proportion. Just something to think about. I know its a pain to redo something, but it's better to do that before you put the knife to it. I filed through two patchbox finials after I had inletted them. Had to Make a new hinge barrel, fit the hinge to the lid, recut them, and inlet it back into the existing mortise. Talk about a pain in the a___!! One other thing that you should remember is that brass work hardens, make sure it's annealed well at the start of inletting. Another problem I had I couldn't understand, I couldn't get the finial to lay flat in the inletted stock so I kept going deeper, and when I filed it flush with stock, I caught myself just in time before I filed through that one too. It just needed to be annealed again and tweaked a little.
I wish I had this forum when I first got started, I wouldn't of made as many mistakes, but making them gave me more confidence and experience...
........Good luck......George F.