3F is your friend. Crud ring is normal if you don't use a proper wet lube to prevent it. Mark your rammer so you are sure the ball is fully seated every time.
Just powder with patched ball. Work up your load on a hot dry day, using spit patch. Increase until the fouling is blown clear of the barrel. If you AREN'T getting the ring, you may wish to reduce the load until you do, then work back up. This method gives you the most effective charge for a smoothbore. Any thing more is a waste, and anything less, means more fouling.That's one I had not heard yet. Increase both powder and shot?
A more sure and accurate method of working a bore into match shape is lead slug hand lapping with various grades of lapping compound. This will tell you exactly the diameters and texture of your bore as you can actually feel a ten thousands of an inch change in diameter.Allow me to start with a word of background, the rifle was bought new and has been exhibiting what I'm about to say since day 1.
I'm the kind of guy who likes to swab his barrel between shots. What became immediately apparent is that there is a spot in the barrel where the resistance to the patch increases then abates as the point is passed. As if a ring has formed within the barrel. If I swab a clean barrel it isn't there, only after shooting. I have a therory but would like to hear what others may think, I've always used olive oil as a lube. The last is what my theory is based on. I'd have to chew leaf to get enough spit, and I gave that up years ago.
A bulge, which is the "ring" mentioned above would be detected by feeling the cleaning jag loosen as it entered the bulged section of the barrel. The buildup of a crud ring is detected by an increase in the effort to get the cleaning patch past the crud ring. The ring mentioned by @Trgt is most likely to be a crud ring caused by an accumulation of fouling about where the ball and patch are located when loaded. It's common and can be easily removed by a dampened cleaning patch. You want a slightly undersized jag and patch to pass through the ring then bunch up to pull the fouling out. We don't want to push fouling down in ton the firing chamber to block the flash channel.But before that part he said when loading it became immediately apparent that a tight spot was passed in the bore. I'm sure he is assuming this is only a rough spot in the bore from reaming or rifling that is hooking fouling but it could also be a pressure ring enlargement causing the trouble when the patched ball engages the off side of the ring after passing the swelled area. Hopefully this is not the trouble but it should be checked.
The other thing is the position of the fouling ring in the barrel as most pressure bulges are generally farther up bore where as a fouling ring will generally be in the same area as a patched ball is seated over a fresh powder charge.A bulge, which is the "ring" mentioned above would be detected by feeling the cleaning jag loosen as it entered the bulged section of the barrel. The buildup of a crud ring is detected by an increase in the effort to get the cleaning patch past the crud ring. The ring mentioned by @Trgt is most likely to be a crud ring caused by an accumulation of fouling about where the ball and patch are located when loaded. It's common and can be easily removed by a dampened cleaning patch. You want a slightly undersized jag and patch to pass through the ring then bunch up to pull the fouling out. We don't want to push fouling down in ton the firing chamber to block the flash channel.
Enter your email address to join: