Questions on sourcing junk pewter

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Hank Mcmauser

36 Cl.
Joined
Dec 30, 2024
Messages
57
Reaction score
96
Location
Florida
Stopped by a 2nd hand junk store today and saw this mug, and a serving set (2nd pic) would either of these be a good candidate for smelting down to pour a nosecap? The mug was marked $12, and the serving set had 4 pieces for $15. Seems as it it is it would be better than paying shipping on an ingot of alloy from a vendor
 

Attachments

  • 20250106_104154.jpg
    20250106_104154.jpg
    1,022.6 KB
  • 20250106_104342(0).jpg
    20250106_104342(0).jpg
    2.1 MB
Track of the wolf gets $13/lb. + tax & shipping for pewter ingots. If either of the items you were looking at weighed a pound or more you could save a little and if you bought both you could probably haggle the price down some. Recycling pewterware is a good way to save just don't melt anything that has historic value or is collectable. Single items, incomplete sets and things like that mug don't fall into that category.
 
Bro!?!?!?!? Don't melt down the TRIPLE CROWN HALL OF FRIGGIN FAME GOBLET! Someone's Great uncle has been searching for that cup and will pay every bit of $6 and 20 minute conversation on how "these damn kids don't know how good they got it!"...

Don't let a good deal GO TO WASTE!



/s
 
I'm a sucker for pewter mugs that have embossing and/or emblems on them. I can't bring myself to melting them down for nose caps and such. I have babbitt bearing material and linotype for such things.
I have no issues with putting a torch to any pewter plates or any other pewter items that are plane jane items of no value.
 
I've always used tin for nose caps. I've read that it's use was common in the old days. I like the way it looks better than pewter but that's just my opinion. It keeps it's shine and doesn't tarnish. I get my tin for little or nothing at garage and estate sales in the form of 95/5 solder.
 
Well, I went back there today and picked up the mug. I also picked up the pewter snap-on belt buckle at the goodwill outlet for $.99/# unsure about melting that as I may find a snap on fan boy that needs it more than I do. Also snagged the brass house number that is going to become my front sight.
 

Attachments

  • 20250108_192734.jpg
    20250108_192734.jpg
    2 MB
  • 20250108_192806.jpg
    20250108_192806.jpg
    2.4 MB
Well I should have left that mug, apparently it's aluminum, the torch didn't begin to melt it, however that pretty snap-on 75th anniversary belt buckle sure is pewter. It is now my nose cap. I used an arizona iced tea can for my form, used a little bit of modeling clay to form a block, and blue taped the bottom edge of the can. It's not as nice as If like but it's going to do alright. I got the front sight made and installed and I'm working on the ramrod pipes (1/2" steel tubing)and the ramrod. I'm going poor mountain boy syyle on this rifle and using a nice fairly straight section of river cane I harvested in late '23 for making arrows. I will need to finish drilling the stock for the ramrod. Install the pipes, dovetail the barrel for the pinning tennons, and the rear sight ,make and install the rear sight, and start making some of that magical go boom powder. I'm probably going to shoot this a dozen or so times and hang it on the wall afterwards. As I've got a CVA Mountaineer on its way soon, and it will be for regular duty.
 

Attachments

  • 20250112_214444.jpg
    20250112_214444.jpg
    1.7 MB
Made another good haul today, if anyone is in the Dothan Al. I urge them to stop in to the little store on business 231 with all of the bicycles on the front facade called Dothan Thrift store. Shorty made me a good deal on some pewter, and a cast iron 3 qt pot. All of this for $17.
 

Attachments

  • 20250131_164115.jpg
    20250131_164115.jpg
    812.5 KB
  • 20250131_174624.jpg
    20250131_174624.jpg
    2.5 MB
Please, do not melt down historic items for scrap. That's what people have done since the Spanish melted down all the Aztec art and sacred pieces in the 1500s. Today it's silver and now I see pewter. To make 10% more than you pay, you destroy antiques? If they're not antiques, I guess it's ok, but I see some in these photos.
Many (most) collecting worlds bemoan what has been lost "...in the great WWI scrap drives...WWII drives...during the 1950s when nowbody cared about ..." etc, etc. We lose more history every antique fair, as scrappers prowl around grabbing up every sterling hat pin or baby cup...all to sell and melt into ingots? It's sick.

I bought a ABP crystal bowl yesterday at an antique fair. It had a black metal rim. I knew what it was, the seller, nor the scrappers did. It's rim was Sterling. But better yet for me, a historian, it is Gorham silver, hallmark dates it to 1898. It took a worker 2 days at cutting and polishing to make this in the 1800s. He had good wages and was middle class. Today it's worth about $250. I paid $10. A scrapper whould have broken the crystal bowl to get at the silver rim, ripped it off the shards, and gotten....$18.
 
Last edited:
Give me the bad news , is one of these worth thousands of dollars?
I did an ebay search, and there's several just like these for sale, $12 + shipping and there not getting any bids. I don't think the world's going to stop spinning if a few cups and saucers get melted down.
 
Well I should have left that mug, apparently it's aluminum, the torch didn't begin to melt it, however that pretty snap-on 75th anniversary belt buckle sure is pewter. It is now my nose cap. I used an arizona iced tea can for my form, used a little bit of modeling clay to form a block, and blue taped the bottom edge of the can. It's not as nice as If like but it's going to do alright. I got the front sight made and installed and I'm working on the ramrod pipes (1/2" steel tubing)and the ramrod. I'm going poor mountain boy syyle on this rifle and using a nice fairly straight section of river cane I harvested in late '23 for making arrows. I will need to finish drilling the stock for the ramrod. Install the pipes, dovetail the barrel for the pinning tennons, and the rear sight ,make and install the rear sight, and start making some of that magical go boom powder. I'm probably going to shoot this a dozen or so times and hang it on the wall afterwards. As I've got a CVA Mountaineer on its way soon, and it will be for regular duty.
A lot of stuff that antique stores & thrift stores sell as "pewter" is in fact Armetal - an aluminum alloy that looks similar to pewter.
 
Please, do not melt down historic items for scrap. That's what people have done since the Spanish melted down all the Aztec art and sacred pieces in the 1500s. Today it's silver and now I see pewter. To make 10% more than you pay, you destroy antiques? If they're not antiques, I guess it's ok, but I see some in these photos.
Many (most) collecting worlds bemoan what has been lost "...in the great WWI scrap drives...WWII drives...during the 1950s when nowbody cared about ..." etc, etc. We lose more history every antique fair, as scrappers prowl around grabbing up every sterling hat pin or baby cup...all to sell and melt into ingots? It's sick.

I bought a ABP crystal bowl yesterday at an antique fair. It had a black metal rim. I knew what it was, the seller, nor the scrappers did. It's rim was Sterling. But better yet for me, a historian, it is Gorham silver, hallmark dates it to 1898. It took a worker 2 days at cutting and polishing to make this in the 1800s. He had good wages and was middle class. Today it's worth about $250. I paid $10. A scrapper whould have broken the crystal bowl to get at the silver rim, ripped it off the shards, and gotten....$18.
Some Pewter Items were made by Wilton in Pa. Did lots of commemorative items
Not exactly worth a fortune but collectable.
 
I did an ebay search, and there's several just like these for sale, $12 + shipping and there not getting any bids. I don't think the world's going to stop spinning if a few cups and saucers get melted down.
Hank you can also make a mould from a clay called Sculpty.
You bake it in the oven to harden it and it stands up well.
can be had at arts and craft stores.
 
Made another good haul today, if anyone is in the Dothan Al. I urge them to stop in to the little store on business 231 with all of the bicycles on the front facade called Dothan Thrift store. Shorty made me a good deal on some pewter, and a cast iron 3 qt pot. All of this for $17.
Most of your second load is silver plate- I buy pewter for casting- you should look for non period pieces- 1960s holland pewter is usually useful, but sets and rare pieces even if they look bad need to be researched prior to melting- I prefer to meltcocktails shakers
 

Latest posts

Back
Top