• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Remember your First ML kill?

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I was sitting just below the top edge of a small glen with a long since unused fence post and a few weeds for cover. About 9:30 a nice buck casually came down the bottom hopping the meandering little creek as he went, just when I figured he was within my range and stood still he bedded. Now all I could see was the tips of his tines. Three times he got up and looked around, took a leak and before I could get a good sight picture on him he was back down. I was using a Centermark .62 fusil-de-chase with a rear sight, I had worked real hard, and experimented a great deal to become confident with out to eighty yards. The last time he got up and looked around, I knew he was leaving, he took a couple steps and stood, I was on him and felt the gun go off. It was a beautiful cold, calm, clear day and the smoke hung like a pall, as it rose I saw he was still standing, as he turned, my mind was screaming 'how could I miss', two steps and he keeled over, I remembered to breath. It was 1:30. At about sixty plus yards I hit exactly where I had aimed, a nine point and biggest rack to date. I was overjoyed, thankful, and humbled.
Robby
 
Sorry had a hard time adding picture this morning
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20221011-091854.png
    Screenshot_20221011-091854.png
    1.5 MB
In 1986 only smooth bore shotguns, pistols of .357 and larger muzzleloaders were permitted for deer in Ohio. I choose the muzzleloader, as rifles appeal the most to my sensibilities, and Grandpa had given Dad a T/C .45 Hawkin. That season I shot a young buck but very low. It lived another day.
The next season I purchased a T/C Renegade in .50 cal. On a very cold afternoon three does were slipping through the samplings a mere 10 yards from the tractor path I was standing in when buck fever set in. When the lead doe stepped out into a small opening about 25 yards in front of my position it was all I could do to keep the sights on her chest. I willed my finger to pull the trigger, after which she disappeared in two steps. The dry leaves reported her direction of travel and the loud skid in those same leaves gave some assurance that my shot may have been true.
Man, what a feeling to finally find that highway of a blood trail and see her piled up at its end.
 
It was 1987. My boss was a civil war re-enactor. I borrowed his 1861 Springfield for the Michigan muzzleloader deer season. .58 Minie ball (hollow base conical).
I saw what I thought was a doe, and I took the 50-60 yard shot. Turned out to be a "button buck".

Now, 35 years later quite a few deer have fallen to my muzzleloaders. I stopped counting at 12. I have three guns that I most often hunt with; .50 percussion Lancaster style longrifle that I built myself; .50 flintlock late Lancaster style longrifle, and a .62 flintlock fowler. All three have 42 inch barrels. The percussion sports a straight octagon barrel. The flintlock rifle has a swamped octagon barrel. The fowler has an octagon to round barrel.
I made my own shot bag, powderhorn, and most of my accoutrements.
 
It was a damp, drizzly, cold day. My hunting buddy arrived at the public hunting area, and returned my old Capote, that I'd lent him a couple weeks before at a living history event. We loaded up and walked toward the area where the woods opened up into a clearing. My buddy is considered fully disabled, with a constant pain situation from slipping and falling on the floor in a professional kitchen. He has his good days and bad days, and this day as we walked he stepped on top of a tiny, frozen puddle. His bad leg slipped, moving in an odd direction and he was done for the day. Not only was there more pain, but it looked like he pulled a hamstring OUCH. So I helped him hobble back to the cars. So the day wouldn't be a total bust..., I showed him a farm near by where they raised chukkar and other birds for upland hunting preserves, and he bought several chukkar to take home as he was going to cook for his ailing father. My buddy then begged me to go back and at least try an afternoon hunt ; he was feeling guilty that things had gotten screwed up, even though I approached the whole thing as "crap happens ; no biggie".

So he drove home and I went back to the public area. One of the things that I've learned is that public hunting areas are best Tuesdays through Thursdays, in the afternoons, during a normal week (not a week that starts with a Monday holiday for example). You see, folks can take Monday off, or Friday off, and are off weekends, BUT..., Tuesday through Thursday, most people can't take the whole day. They take half-days, AND those are morning, half-days because they know that if they try to take the afternoon off, some silliness will happen and work and they won't be able to leave, so.... IF they hunt Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday, it's a morning half-day.

Now deer, in the public areas, (in my observation and opinion) hear all these guys arrive before dawn, and tramp into the woods, stomp stomp stomp stomp. The guys also kick up a lot of earth-scent. The deer know to move toward the edges or boundaries of the public areas, and to hunker down. The hunters often don't go really close to the public area property line in case a deer might stray onto private land or no-hunt state land (like where the power company transfer station sits). The deer then simply hole-up and listen for folks to leave.

Which is why I hunt "all day", without a midday break. As such, even though these days I'm mostly on private land that is adjacent to the public areas, I've gotten more deer between noon and 4 p.m. than I have within two hours of dawn or sundown. I found on the public land, the deer can't count. 😆 So a dozen guys tromp into the area before dawn, including me. Then because the other eleven guys only got a half-day off from work, they leave at 11 a.m. and the dear..., hear them leave.... but I am still quiet and in my spot. They don't think "Hey I heard 12 guys come in but only 11 left." NOPE.

The human scent dies down because there is only one human left. The scent from all the disturbed soil dies down. It gets really quiet..., and by around 2 p.m. the deer are getting hungry (btw the colder or wetter the weather the more the deer need to eat ;)) SO the deer that sooo many guys have told me are "nocturnal" start moving around 2-3 p.m. That's what I was hoping when I went back to the hunting area that morning. I'd get in and wait.

So I arrived at about 1 pm. and it had been drizzling off and on all morning, which I like as it really scrubs the air of scent. The damp ground means no leaves crunching as I step as well. I actually saw some other hunters walking out, which was also very good. I was right on time.

I got out of my car and decided to don that old Capote that my buddy had returned to me. I said when I lent it to him not to clean it, as I had a special procedure for that. It was from a wool blanket after all. So out to the hunting spot I trod. I found my favorite walnut tree, and scraped a spot on the ground to stand so that no twigs or anything else would make noise.

It started to drizzle, and I realized that I had forgotten my cow's knee to cover my flintlock lock. No matter, I tucked the lock area up under my arm and thus beneath the Capote, and unless a tropical storm hit, the lock would stay dry. THEN IT HIT ME.

The massively cloying scent of "Afternoon Spring" assaulted my senses, and it was coming from the Capote that I had said "don't clean this". My buddy's wife had tossed the Capote into the washing machine with a scoop of Cheer "Afternoon Spring" scented detergent. The Capote still fit, so she had hung it up to dry instead of tossing it into the drier, BUT it REEKED of unnatural perfume, and of course she cleaned it as it had smelled of hardwood smoke. (Well gee we can't have that smoky scent, can we? 😫) So..., if I could SMELL the artificial scent with my human nose, then DEER WOULD with their noses.

Sure enough..., behind me to the south as I faced north into the clearing, was a thicket. A good place for deer to hide to be sure, but way too thick for me to see for any sort of a shot, and when the wind shifted from East to West..., to coming into my face, blowing past me taking scent South into the thicket, I heard (but never saw) several doe..., blow. You know..., blow..., that quick WHEEEW snort that they do when they suddenly pick up a distasteful scent. They were so loud they had to be within fifty FEET of me, and then thundered off away from me. I heard them go and muttered, "I don't blame you, ladies ; this thing reeks to high heaven."

But I stayed. The drizzle was constant now but very light and..., I couldn't see through the brush to the South, and that's the direction my scent was going with the wind so no real loss. Around 3:30 I saw movement to the northeast. A doe was creeping through the area. If she continued she'd step out of the trees into the clearing. I placed the palm of my off hand flat against the walnut tree with my left thumb out, acting as a "hook" to support my rifle as I brought her up to sight at the area where the deer would appear unobstructed by saplings. When the doe got to the edge of the clearing I cocked my .54 caliber longrifle. I could see her fine, but the sweet spot behind the shoulder where the lungs lay was covered by a tree trunk growing between us. The doe heard the "click" of the lock being pulled to full ****, and paused (DANG!). Then slowly she stepped forward into my sight picture. The rifle was tight against my shoulder and my pounding heart (first time deer ever folks) was making the front sight post move a bit. I touched off the rifle.

BOOM she went, but the drizzly weather caused that great cloud of smoke to hang there for a long long time. I didn't see the deer run off, but I reloaded, and waited a few minutes to get my heart rate back down and to be able to hear again something other than my own pulse in my ears. I walked over to find where the deer had been standing to start my tracking, and discovered that I had not seen nor heard the deer run off, because it dropped in place. I paced off the shot and it was about 30 yards. 70 grains of 3Fg launched a patched .530 round ball through the doe.

THAT was my first deer ever. OH I had been out deer hunting in the past, but always had managed to share in somebody else's deer, never having had a successful first shot before.

I've never hunted dear since with anything other than a flintlock. ;)

LD
 
6 point 10 yards with Traditions 50 cal Hawkins neck shot,had a head full of hair and it was brown,those were the days
 
I grew up bowhunting and did that exclusively for over 25 years before I decided to add muzzleloading to my hobbies to give me a little better chance for very spooky late season whitetails. That was in 2000. I bought a 50 cal TC.

My first morning out in December was bitter cold. I was hunting a steep hillside on a friend's property sitting on the ground. A few hours into the sit, and questioning my sanity for sitting in below zero weather, a noise erupted and a string of around twenty deer came trotting down the trail lead by a large doe.

Immediately brought my gun up and tracked the doe through the brush, but there would not be a shot opportunity until she was REALLY close due to the trail they were on. At less than 10 yards and with only a step or two to go to clear the brush, the big old doe finally saw me and put the brakes on hard! The "train wreck" that ensued was almost comical as the other deer started plowing into each other's rear ends due to their leader's abrupt halt! The net was that the doe directly behind the leader finally got shoved forward into the big lead doe who was pushed forward just clear of the brush. KABOOM!!!

Through the smoke all I could see was obscured bodies flying everywhere! Suddenly, about twenty yards down the hill, I saw one flopping around. For a split second I thought it was the big doe going down, but nope, it was a small doe with her head caught in an old sheep fence! She got herself out quickly, the smoke cleared, and all the deer were gone.

In the malay I did remember that the lead doe had bolted past me on the same trail, so I started my search for blood (no snow) down that trail. 50 yards ... nothing. I couldn't have missed at eight yards! I went back and looked down another trail and about 20 yards in found a huge blood trail. She was down after an 80 yard run to...of course...the bottom of the hill.

She field dressed at 157#, which is the largest doe I have ever taken. With her thick winter coat and large size, I decided to have a mount done like one I saw at a deer expo a few years before that had the tail sticking up behind the mount. Now I look at her frequently and recall that hunt 22 years ago as if it was yesterday.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20221103_085922.jpg
    IMG_20221103_085922.jpg
    4.6 MB
Last edited:
First with ML was 1975. I had gotten a TC Hawken 50 for Christmas from my wife. I shot it quite a bit and felt pretty confident. It wasn't as easy then to learn the fine points of ml shooting but I got with some experienced guys at a local club shoot and they gave me a lot of pointers. One of those guys was Ron Long. A really good guy with super shooting credentials. He later got more into BPCR where he also distinguished himself. He passed away recently.

So, by the time the '75 seasons were coming around Iwas ready. I took a nice medium sized 4 x 4 mulie on the side of a steep ravine. He ran, rolled and tumbled to the bottom. It was a project getting him out! Shot 90 grains of goex 2f and a patched 490 ball that I cast on the kitchen stove.
 
89B98B40-8218-4DDA-A560-41D73235C2A3.jpeg
631B2F26-7A5B-456C-AFE2-5CE4D834FBD7.jpeg

It’s been nearly 10 years since my first muzzleloader kill. I don’t think I’ve missed a Kansas muzzleloader season since. This was about a 70 yard shot with a .40 poorboy I shot for used. It’s been since shelved in the gun safe for my .58 flintlock
 
My first and so far only muzzleloader kill was this fat doe I took on the last day of PA's early muzzleloader season a couple weeks ago, about 45 minutes before closing time. I used my Cabela's (Investarm) Hawken caplock .50. My load was a .490 PRB on top of 70 grains of Goex 3Fg and the range was about 55 yards.

Full story here.

170821-102222-DM-doe.jpg
 
I honestly don’t remember my first ML kill - it was many years ago. I do know it was with a Lyman GPR in 50 caliber. I still have that rifle and my son hunts with it now.

I can tell you about my 1st ML kill with a flintlock because it was yesterday. A while back I found and made a deal on a .62 Jaeger. I have since pretty much fallen in love with the thing.

Yesterday was opening day of gun season for deer here in Texas. I was out with my son just because that’s what we do, right? We were both watching trails where we had seen action. I was hunkered down, backed up in a nice piece of scrub brush. I had the wind the way I wanted. (As a side note I have always hunted this way. I have never owned a blind. Nothing against them - I just subscribe to the “be still and be quiet” philosophy)

About 1 1/2 hours after 1st light I heard some rocks move behind me - I mean like 15-20 feet behind me. I looked to my left to see a big coyote move around the brush I was sitting in. He hadn’t seen me yet - he just knew something wasn’t right. He was maybe 5-6 yards away. He began to trot off slowly crossing from left to right at about a 45 degree angle.

I rolled over from sitting into kneeling as I cocked the hammer and brought up the gun. I had to follow him in the sights until an opening presented itself. I could see him clearly but there were weeds and light brush in the way. When he was maybe 25 yards away I had a shot. He was moving, but agin just a slow trot. I followed and squeezed the trigger.

If there was any real delay in ignition I didn’t notice. The gun went off flawlessly. Through the smoke I saw the coyote spin and knew he was hit well. He growled for a second which was both cool and slightly terrifying with an unloaded gun - but he then expired and all was over.

I haven’t had the shakes in - goodness - over 30 years but this made me do it. There was something about using a flintlock in this kind of situation that was special. I doubt I will forget this one.

For those that like to know I used a .610 RB, lubed felt wad over powder, .018” pillow ticking patch lubed with TOTW mink oil.

5B3E9091-EC3C-4E1B-A180-D401094D7CC6.jpeg
 
"I have never owned a blind. Nothing against them - I just subscribe to the “be still and be quiet” philosophy)"

I agree, the most enjoyable way to hunt. Excellent shot on the coyote.
 
If you guys can remember your first kill with a ML, let’s hear about it. Remember, we love pics so if you have a pic of that first kill share it with us if you would.

The only thing I’ve killed with a traditional ML is a few squirrels. I can say that I vividly remember it though. Punched a perfect 50 ca hole thru him. Killed a bunch of squirrels with that first rifle, killed a bunch of deer with a modern ML, but not a traditional one. Hoping to change that this season. Should changed last season, but I kept coming up with new and exciting ways to screw it up.
A bear, a couple weeks ago.
 

Attachments

  • D566A3DD-2AC0-4CEC-A653-21CE682780BA.jpeg
    D566A3DD-2AC0-4CEC-A653-21CE682780BA.jpeg
    132.8 KB
I was hunting a river bottom adjacent to some hay fields. Some muleys came by with a nice buck in the group but the landowner had allowed me to hunt a) black powder, and b) whitetails only.
It was exciting to watch the deer feed by at 40 yards, and gave me some confidence in my 'ground blind' - a tree that had blown over most of the way, offering a place to stand sit just behind it with something to break up my contour. I hunt with ear muffs and safety glasses, plus hunter orange as required. Deer will look at me but just shrug and move on if my silhouette is broken up and I'm still. Just as the sun was setting behind me a young 3x3 whitetail appeared on the same trail as the muleys. At 40 yards a .530 RB impacted tight behind the shoulder and the deer ran directly past me about 50 yards before falling to a perfect hit. I was running about 80 grains of 2F GOEX and shooting a .015 patch.
I was thrilled, and realized that I'd never chase deer with modern weapons again. This was 2005, and I haven't gone back on that. I'm grateful to have discovered this community.
 
Back
Top